2005 Chevrolet Monte Carlo Overview, Reviews, Ratings & Specs

2007 2006 2005 2004 2003 2002 2001

Crash Test Rating

Source NHTSA

MPG (up to)

19 -21 City / 28 -32 HWY

Source FuelEconomy.gov

Horsepower

180 -240

Seats

Positive Owner Reviews

Aaron T

It is reliable car that is never broke down all the years I have had it.

Nothing wrong with it great for moving around in city while having a sporty look I can rely on this car whenever I need to get where I need to go.

Arron W

Intimidator Dale Earnhardt addition it burn rubber

Well it has a supercharger it's a 3800 it's fast reliable comfortable about of trunk space power windows power locks power seats heated seats nice leather seats it tells me exactly how much gas is in the tank and more

Carla C

It is old and has a lot of miles but is trustworthy and still a good car.

My Monte Carlo is a 2005 model. I bought it used in 2006 with about 30 thousand miles. It has been well taken care of, currently has 225 thousand miles.

Joshua R

Monte Carlos are sleek and fast

My Chevrolet Monte Carlo is very reliable. It goes fast. It is a very cool looking vehicle that people are jealous of. The interior is nice too. The steering wheel radio controls work great, as do all the other electronic components of the vehicle. The only issue I've had it with the power steering system. Also the speedometer quit working and displays an incorrect speed.

Ashley D

My Monte Carlo, but I call her Carla.

This is a great car! She's roomy and sporty. The trunk is big enough you can sleep in it, so a Costco run is no issue. The ride itself is smooth. The interior is leather, so I tinted the windows so my skin does not fry in the summer sun. She fits anywhere. Just cannot go over large bumps or 4-wheeling. The self-starter takes some getting used to, so used to key cranking that having my car do it for me just seems wrong. The light turns green and she takes off like a dream. The upkeep costs are low. Keep her fluids up and changed as needed and she'll run forever. Best car I have ever had!

Edith W

Monte Carlo my personal luxury car at a decent price

Car has been very dependable. It has 168,700 miles on it. When it was brand new we had SiriusXM. It is still available. It came fully loaded. I love using the sunroof on nice days. The black leather seats have worn over the years, but after almost 15 years I really can't complain. The car will seat 5 adults comfortably. The back seat lays down so you can haul long items.

Bob J

Low mileage It is in very good shape

I like the style and performance.The gas mileage is good.The seats are comfortable

Pamela T

It is rare. You might not be able to find one to buy.

I like the power and weight I feel when I get behind the steering wheel, and it is easy to drive. It also has heated seats. I hate the seat belts. They could have designed the seat belts better. I also wish Chevrolet was still making this car.

Negative Owner Reviews

Breanna C

This car is a nightmare. I hate it I want to get rid of it.

I hate the way this car looks, it's so ugly. The horn doesn't work. And the tachometer doesn't work. It has given me a lot of trouble since I've had it. It had some major electrical issues that we could never figure out. I hate how I can't turn off the headlights while the car is on.

Dorothy H

It runs good but has an evap leak.

It has an eval leak and the speedometer does not work. The hood needs painting and there are dents and scratches all over and the seats need shampooing and some thing need to be glued in place inside.

Starr W

It runs good for a very long time.

I love how my car is very comfortable and how easily the acceleration is as well. Even though it is an older car it still drives very good, especially if you take car of the car which is very important. It does not cost a lot to fill up the gas tank, which is awesome since gas prices are going up.

Emily D

Decent car, good longevity, some issues.

My monte Carlo is a beast. It is has 200k+ miles on it and is still chugging away. It is got great durability. It is a larger vehicle so it can be slightly difficult to maneuver. But it has lots of space on the inside as well as a large trunk that can open up to the cabin. Because of its size, the brakes go bad faster as is typically the case with this model. This is not the car I would have chosen for myself (I am short and like smaller cars), but it was the right price from a friend. It has been decently reliable for its age and I am grateful that it is still working well (heat & ac are great).

Jennifer R

Problematic 2005 Monte Carlo

My 2005 Chevrolet Monte Carlo has power windows and driver side seat. I currently have a recall for the ignition switch and everytime I turn around something is going wrong with it. I've had thousands of dollars worth of work on it and seems like I'm only going to spend thousands more. In the long run, it'll probably be cheaper to just buy a new car. It has gotten me from point "A" to point "B" however I don't feel as if I'm getting the gas mileage as I should.

Brittany S

Great first vehicle for anyone learning to drive!

It is a smaller vehicle which makes it great for a single person. Not great during snow or heavy rain. Very low to ground which makes it difficult for steep driveways. The trunk is incredibly spacious allowing you to move many items. It is also very easy to handle and makes for a perfect first vehicle!

Eric B

Old Reliable: Built for the long haul

It's old and outdated as of now but it's lasted me for over 14 years. There only time I had issues was when the radiator needed replacing. Other than that regular maintenance has kept it running smoothly. Currently have 120,000 Miles and counting. Definitely built to last.

Alice N

A Great Car for a New Driver Just Starting Out

Despite being almost 15 years old, the Monte Carlo has held up nicely. My only complaint for the car is that it a very long car and that takes some time to get used to, particularly in regards to turning and parking the vehicle. The interior of the car has been able to maintain itself throughout the years and overall I would rate this a pretty decent car, particularly a first car.

Chevrolet Monte Carlo Models

Models also known as Trim Levels, are used to identify a vehicle's level of equipment or special features.

180 HP 27-27 MPG 5 Seats

200 HP 25-25 MPG 5 Seats

Supercharged SS

240 HP 24-24 MPG 5 Seats

Photos may not match model

2005 Chevrolet Monte Carlo Owner Reviews

3.92

37 Reviews

Write Review

5 stars

35%

4 stars

30%

3 stars

30%

2 stars

1 star

Alonso M on March 5, 2021

Great performance Monte Carlo.

My Monte Carlo is very reliable, if you do oil changes and regular maintenance it will work, the only problem is that it has over 200, 000 miles, Chevrolet stopped making them in 2006. I wish they brought them back again, I will buy one in a heartbeat, I am trying to keep it as long as possible.

Alonso M on November 10, 2020

The engine is great, likes to run fast.

Chevy does not make Monte-Carlos since 2006; great performance car, very reliable. You do have change the rotter every 5 years or so, if you keep the fluid fresh it will last. My car is 13 years plus.

View All Reviews (37)

Pros from Owners

Molly S.

It gets very good gas mileage and has been very low maintenance since I have had it. I have been very satisfied with the performance of the vehicle. I had wanted that model for quite some time and I am not disappointed that I waited to get it.

Kevin R.

This vehicle has a V6 Engine providing plenty of horsepower for those who look for that, and it also has a good suspension for the year it was made. While it is a coupe there is plenty of legroom for rear passengers and lots of trunk space.

Cons from Owners

Molly S.

Only having two doors makes it hard to take all of the grandkids places. I have found that the exhaust needs repair and that parts are sometimes expensive. The trunk space is okay except for spare tire being in the compartment.

Kevin R.

The gas mileage is pretty poor compared to newer cars. Usual combined mileage is somewhere around 16-18 MPG. Buying this car used as well means an number of things could be wrong with it at this point since it is a 15 year old car.

Ranks #13 Midsize Cars by Owners

The 2005 Chevrolet Monte Carlo has an average owner rating of 3.92 out of 5 which ranks it #13 of 14 other Midsize Cars.

2005 Toyota Camry

4.37

2005 Honda Accord

4.32

2005 Chevrolet Monte Carlo

3.92

Ranks #3 Midsize Cars by Fuel Economy

The 2005 Chevrolet Monte Carlo has a combined MPG of 32 which ranks it #3 of 15 other Midsize Cars.

2005 Honda Accord

34 MPG

2005 Toyota Camry

34 MPG

2005 Chevrolet Monte Carlo

32 MPG

Is The 2005 Chevrolet Monte Carlo A Good Car?

It is very good. I have only made one major repair. The gas mileage is very good too. I would recommend it to anyone.

Molly S.

Yes, it gets me where I need to go without too many problems. It runs good and is safe. It is also a good looking car.

Hayden L.

How Reliable Is The 2005 Chevrolet Monte Carlo?

The only problem I have had is replacing the fuel pump. That is not problematic to me, just routine wear and tear.

Molly S.

It has always been very reliable for me. The problems that I have had are all due to its age and use. Most maintenance has been routine.

Stewart M.

Is The 2005 Chevrolet Monte Carlo A Good Value?

The last I checked on prices about 3 1/2 years ago, it cost $4000 at a car lot. I think that is a very good price.

Molly S.

When I originally purchased it, the car cost about $26,000. It has been a good car for its value. The same car today would cost around $40,000.

Bonnie R.

Safety & Reliability

NHTSA Crash Test

Overall

Front

Rollover

Side

*National Highway Traffic Safety Administration

IIHS Crash Test

(Not Tested)

*Insurance Institute for Highway Safety