KBB Logo Expert review written by the Kelley Blue Book vehicle review editorial team.

You'll Like The 2011 Ford Mustang If...

While its strongest appeal will be to the Mustang faithful, the latest iteration of this American icon now has the look, feel and features that should make it worthy of consideration by anyone shopping for a sporty, rear-drive two-door. The SYNC audio system and the V6’s impressive fuel economy are two huge selling points unmatched by the Mustang’s competitors.

You May Not Like The 2011 Ford Mustang If...

Those who demand the biggest horsepower numbers without stepping into far-pricier Shelby GT500 territory will find the Chevrolet Camaro SS packs a bit more punch under its hood than the Mustang GT. As in the past, limited head/leg room relegate Mustang’s aft quarters to a de facto kids-only zone.

What's New

For 2011, the Mustang receives two new engine choices: an all-aluminum 3.7-liter V6, and a 5.0-liter V8. Both engines can be fitted with a choice of six-speed manual or automatic transmissions, while the V6 models receive as standard a limited-slip differential. The 2011 Mustang receive a new electrically assisted power steering unit and improvements to its suspension, frame stiffness and interior NVH (noise, vibration and harshness) levels.

Interior Features

If the Mustang holds a superior advantage over its arch-rival, the Chevrolet Camaro, it’s inside the cockpit. Classic design themes are interwoven with upscale details such as a one-piece soft-touch dash set off by brushed aluminum and bright-chrome accents. A new instrument cluster includes a 160-mph speedometer and the center stack has a more logical and usable layout for the audio, heat/air-conditioning controls and standard displays – or the eight-inch color touch screen that’s included with the optional navigation system. New features include the addition of a driver’s message center and the availability of Ford’s MyKey programmable vehicle key. Additional attention has been paid to sound proofing, including new door seals and thicker glass. The Mustang’s front buckets offer better comfort and support than the Camaro, while the rear bench – a 60/40 fold-down in the Coupe but fixed in the Convertible – is scaled for small to mid-size kids.

Exterior Features

Last year’s redesign saw a two-year Mustang makeover that began with the car’s exterior. A complete re-skin put a finer edge on the Mustang’s classically proportioned design while resurrecting several historical elements. The more aggressive bodywork includes a power-bulged hood and cleaner, crisper individualized fascia treatments highlighted by an integrated headlamp/turn-indicator unit that revisits the 1970 Mustang and mid-’60s-era sequential tail lamps updated with LED bulbs; 2011 also sees the return of the fabled 5.0-liter badge boldly attached to the GT’s front fenders. A revised grille insert serves as a backdrop for a more stylized galloping pony emblem as well as prominent fog lamps in GT models, which also boast a subtle rear spoiler. New safety features include integrated blind spot mirrors in the side-view mirror housings. The V6s come with 215/60 all-season tires on 17-inch aluminum wheels while the V8 GTs get 235/50 rubber on 18-inch alloys.

Driving Impressions

Ford did an impressive job of remaking the Mustang’s dynamic character for 2010 with a series of well-measured tweaks to the existing suspension setups and tuning elements culled from the Bullitt model. For 2011, Ford finishes the job with two-new engines and transmissions. The new 3.7-liter V6 develops an impressive 305 horsepower, yet somehow manages to earn an EPA highway rating of 31 mpg when equipped with the six-speed automatic. The V6 is refined, quiet and more than capable of making the Mustang’s performance match its looks. Those requiring the loud growl and neck-snapping punch of a V8, however, will be satisfied with nothing less than the new 412-horsepower, 5.0-liter V8. And, Ford’s new six-speed manual no longer feels like something pulled from an old Ranger pickup truck, providing smooth gear transitions and an easily engaged clutch. Recalibration of the springs, shocks and anti-roll bars interact to create a package that’s more comfortable in cruise and more capable in the corners, with better steering feel, quicker overall responses and greater predictability. Complementing this re-mix is a properly restrained and driver-selectable AdvanceTrac stability system that offers a less-restrictive Sport mode on GTs and confidence-inspiring four-wheel anti-lock disc brakes.

Pricing Notes

The Manufacturer’s Suggested Retail Price (MSRP) for a base 2011 Ford Mustang V6 Coupe opens slightly under $23,000; the Premium V6 starts closer to $27,000; an entry GT pushes just past the $30,000 mark; and the Premium GT commands about $34,000. Choosing a Convertible will add about $5,000 to each of those figures, although the unique glass roof option ($1,995) now provides an interesting and more-affordable alternative. To make your best deal, be sure to check its Fair Purchase Price on kbb.com which shows what others in your area are typically paying for their new Mustangs. As for resale, the Mustang V6 is expected edge out the Chevrolet Camaro V6 and Dodge Challenger V6, while the Mustang GT trails just behind in overall five-year residual values.

Notable Equipment

All 2011 Ford Mustang variants are impressively packaged. Even the base V6 comes with air conditioning, power windows/locks/mirrors, keyless remote entry, AM/FM/CD stereo with AUX input, and cruise control plus anti-lock brakes (ABS), Electronic Stability Control (ESC), front/front-side airbags, and Ford’s SOS Post-Crash Alert system. The Premium versions add leather upholstery, trim enhancements, an upgraded instrument cluster with MyColor variable lighting, Shaker 500 audio system with SYNC and SIRIUS Satellite Radio, power driver’s seat and a split/folding rear seat on Coupes. The GTs bring a 412-horsepower, 5.0-liter V8 engine, automatic headlamps, rear spoiler, fog lamps, a black-chrome pony grille badge, and cloth instead of synthetic material on the Convertible’s power top.

Notable Options

Key extras for the base V6 are a six-speed automatic transmission, Security Package (Active Anti-theft System and wheel locks) and a convertible soft boot, while the GT Premium offers the California Package that adds a chrome billet grille, side scoops and 19-inch wheels. The V6 Premium offers the base-level upgrades plus the V6 Performance Package, which brings a strut tower brace, larger anti-roll bars, 19-inch black painted wheels, recalibrated electronic stability control, performance brake pads and a 3.31 rear axle ratio. The GT trim offers the Brembo Brake Package that adds Brembo front brakes, recalibrated stability program and 19-inch wheels surrounded by P255/40R19 summer tires. HID bi-xenon headlamps, a glass roof (Coupe), a back-up camera and several packages – including the Electronic (Navigation with SIRIUS, HD Radio and dual-zone auto climate control) and Comfort (leather-trimmed heated front seats and a six-way power passenger seat) – are available on both Premium variants.

Favorite Features

3.7-liter V6Unless you absolutely revel in the idea of having a V8, the new 3.7-liter V6 is more than enough engine, producing horsepower and torque figures that surpass the output of many previous generation Mustang GTs!Comprehensive Interior UpgradesBetter quality and enhanced features make it a much nicer world inside every 2011 Mustang. Highlighting the mix are a new one-piece soft-touch dash and more finger-friendly controls that are further complemented by variable interior ambient lighting and selectable MyColor illumination for the instrument cluster on Premium models.

Under the Hood

Two new engines anchor the non-Shelby portion of Team Mustang. The base trim is powered by an all-aluminum 3.7-liter V6 engine featuring dual overhead cams (DOHC) and Twin-Independent Variable Camshaft Timing (Ti-VCT). The result is a V6 that produces 305 horsepower, yet delivers fuel economy comparable to some four-cylinder cars. The new six-speed automatic features a ‘Hill Mode" function that extends longer gear operation on uphill climbs and provides additional engine braking upon decent. Ironically, Ford does not offer a manually selectable shift program on this transmission, and odd omission in this category. Stepping up to the new 5.0-liter V8 (also equipped with Ti-VCT technology) brings a big boost in both horsepower and torque, pumping out 412 horsepower and 390 lb.-ft. of torque. Our time in the Mustang GT produced zero-to-60 runs under five-seconds, which is about a second better than the 2010 model.3.7-liter DOHC V6305 horsepower @ 6500 rpm280 lb-ft of torque @ 4250 rpmEPA city/highway fuel economy 19/29 (manual), 19/31 (automatic)5.0-liter DOHC V8412 horsepower @ 6500 rpm390 lb-ft of torque @ 4250 rpmEPA city/highway fuel economy 17/26 (manual), 18/25 (automatic)

Editors' Notes

An icon of Ford’s lineup since the mid-’60s, the rakish Mustang receives the second half of a comprehensive two-year makeover that elevates its horsepower, chassis dynamics and overall bad boy attitude. Feeling the heat from Chevrolet’s recently resurrected Camaro, both Coupe and Convertible Mustangs have been substantially beefed up this year, offering the choice of base and premium trims, all-new V6 or V8 (GT) engines and a choice between a new six-speed manual or six-speed automatic transmission. A formidable roster of standard and available equipment, and some slick new options should help the original pony car gallop on at an even faster pace as it vies for buyers who might also be considering the likes of the Dodge Challenger, Hyundai Genesis Coupe and Chevrolet Camaro. Completing the Mustang range is the 540-horsepower supercharged Shelby GT500, reviewed separately.

Road Test Video Reviews

2011 Ford Mustang Owner Reviews

66 Reviews
62% 29% 5% 2% 3%
Leave your review Would you recommend this vehicle?
(Select your rating)

The exceptional performance of my mustang outweigh any issue I've had.

2011 Ford Mustang V6

First I'll start with problems. Early on I had issues with the gas tank cap/door. The sensor wouldn't sense that it was closed and the indicator light would always warn me that it was open when it was not. The dealership gave me a little funnel that seemed to do the trick so it wasn't too much of an issue when it came time for inspection. Another issue that happened early on was the seat dials. I don't know if it's the battery or the wiring but that also went out within the first 2/3 years. My seat would not move up anymore which made it difficult to reach the pedals. The last thing was the tire pressure sensor always going off and I still don't know why it is so sensitive. Performance wise it's amazing! I love the sensitivity with the pedals and how smooth it feels driving. It is also surprisingly wonderful with gas mileage. The comfortability of the car is nice as well. I love the leather and the bucket type seat of the driver and passenger sides. However the back is a little uncomfortable. I don't think those need to be a bucket type since it's kind of cramped back there anyway. The trunk space is very generous for such a compact coupe. The tires they come with are incredible I have hardly had any problems with them! The convenience of the Bluetooth system is awesome and provides more comfort in my driving experience. Although, I wish it wouldn't automatically connect to my phone and assume that's what I want. Maybe if there were a switch to turn that feature off, it would help. I love how easy it is to change the light colors inside the car. My friends always have a blast with it. Overall, I adore my mustang and think the performance and gas mileage as well as style, outweigh the little issues I had in the beginning!

- Claudia C

2011 Ford Mustang Convertible: Wonderful and reliable

2011 Ford Mustang GT

I love my 2011 Ford Mustang! It gets decent miles per gallon with gas which is important to me as I live about three hours from my family. I also love the turning radius that it has. The easy and sharp turning makes driving very easy. The car in general is an easy driving car as well. One thing that someone might have to get used to if switching to a Mustang would be the long nose of the car. I love it and it does not bother me but when my friends drive my car the long front end makes them nervous as they fear they might hit something when turning or parking, etc. I think comfort-wise that it is good. I as the driver am very comfortable but since Mustangs have small back seats, anyone sitting in the back have no leg room and are often very cramped. So if you are considering purchasing a Mustang and have to drive multiple people around often then I would not recommend this car. My Mustang has proven to be very reliable. I have had the same car for 6 years and have had no trouble with it! Overall, I think the Mustang is a very reliable car and a great investment as well as a vehicle that drives wonderfully. It is amazing for first time drivers or seasoned veterans. I recommend it.

- Kate S

2011 5.0 Mustang Reliability.

2011 Ford Mustang GT

I love my mustang. Always have. However I feel like it is not always reliable. It feels like it's one thing after another with that car. It has 135,000 miles on it despite only being 8 years old. The motor had to be replaced because it was the first year of the new engine in the mustang and there were mistakes in it. Something with the timing belt I believe. The AC system had to be totally redone. There's a few smaller things. It feels like to me it's just a matter of time before the next big and expensive repair needs to be done on it. I do love it though. It's fun to drive, it accelerates quick. The seats are comfortable including the back seats. I also don't like the gas mileage, but that's what you get when you have a muscle car.

- Jordan P

Leave your review