The 2016 Honda Pilot only lasts around 200,000 miles with some serious transmission and engine issues. At $18,200 to $25,250, it’s too expensive for one of the least reliable years for the Pilot.
Is the 2016 Honda Pilot a Good Used SUV?
- Overall Rating 6/10 – 2016 is a bad year for the Honda Pilot with widespread mechanical problems reported, giving it a low overall score. Owner reviews complain about breakdowns, glitchy technology, along with expensive repair bills.
- Interior, Comfort & Cargo 8/10 – Interior materials are very high-end throughout the cabin, the seats hold up well over time, cargo space is also excellent for an SUV.
- Reliability 5/10 – There is a surge in transmission, electrical, as well as engine problems on the 2016 Honda Pilot. Buyers should avoid models from 2016, while 2017–2022 are much more reliable.
- Performance 8/10 – Performance is good from the V6 engine, making the Pilot quicker than other midsize SUVs.
- Safety 8/10 – The 2016 Pilot is a safe SUV, earning a perfect 5 star rating in government crash tests. Standard safety technology includes a rearview camera. Optional features include forward collision warning, automatic braking, lane departure warning & intervention systems.
- Gas Mileage 7/10 – Fuel economy is okay at up to 23 MPG, giving 448 miles of range from the 19.5 gallon tank. Gas costs are average compared to other SUVs, at $258 per month.
- Value 6/10 – Expensive repair bills make the Pilot a bad value proposition for shoppers in the market for a used SUV.
Positive Owner Reviews
Negative Owner Reviews
What Do Critics Say About the Honda Pilot?
- Consumer Reports says the 2016 Pilot lacks the engine refinement that made it sell well in the past, with lower owner satisfaction scores.
- Edmunds rates the Pilot at 3.6/5, praising the comfortable seats, but doesn’t like the overly sensitive collision warning system.
- Kelley Blue Book users give the Pilot a 3.6/5 enjoying the high-tech features, but owners don’t like the expensive repair costs.
What Common Problems Does the 2016 Honda Pilot Have?
Common problems found on the 2016 Honda Pilot include the transmission sharking while shifting between gears, a lot of sensor issues, as well as the engine dying. Overall, these problems are more severe than other midsize SUVs from 2016, even though repair costs are average.
The transmission shaking or jerking while shifting between gears is a widespread complaint from owners at around 45,000 miles. There is a technical service bulletin which addresses some of the problems. They recommend flushing the torque converter and replacing the fluid. If this doesn’t fix the issue, then some owners have had the transmission rebuilt, costing around $3,000.
Sensor issues which lead to fault codes show up on a lot of Pilot models in the first 50,000 miles as well. There are several sensors which wear out as the SUV ages, and have to be replaced. Changing out sensors costs $100 to $600 depending on their location, since some are more complex to replace than others.
The engine dying while driving is another issue mentioned by some owners at around 40,000 miles. In some cases this is also an engine sensor issue, while in others there are camshaft problems. Replacing the camshaft is a very labor-intensive process which costs around $1,800.
There are 5 recalls on the 2016 Honda Pilot, which is similar to other midsize SUVs. The most serious recall covers the fuel tank, which may leak, although it only affects 136 models. Honda will replace the tank on the affected SUVs. Other recalls cover the hood latch, as well as software issues which are not as big of a concern once they’ve been fixed.
How Long Will the 2016 Honda Pilot Last?
A well-maintained 2016 Honda Pilot may last around 200,000 miles, which is around 100,000 miles less than the highly-rated Toyota Highlander. Regular annual maintenance costs are similar to other midsize SUVs, according to data provided by Repair Pal, at $457 per year.
Since many 2016 Honda Pilot models for sale have over 100,000 miles on them, buyers should be prepared to replace the A/C evaporator for $950, the control arm bushings costing $200, as well as the liftgate lock actuators which cost $220.
I haven't experienced any real problems. Although I do keep up with all of the required maintenance and appreciate the fact that the car reminds me when it needs any service.
It is a very reliable vehicle I have had no issues with it,I have only had issues with the key start remote but lucky it was covered under warranty.
For as long as I have used it, I have not had any problems that is extraordinary. It is so reliable.
Have not experienced any issues with my pilot. Only service I have received has been the standard required maintenance. Couldn't have asked for a more reliable SUV.
You buy Honda for its known reliability. I did happen to have a pilot with a defective fuel injector and bar. This was unfortunate and an expensive fix, however, even though my car was past its warranty, Honda did pay for half of the cost to repair it.
It is pretty reliable. I did have an engine issue about 10,000 miles ago. It was replaced with a newer engine. Then just normal wear and tear- needed new battery and new tires.
The vehicle has been very reliable. I have had no problems to date. The GPS is awesome and the big sell for grandkids is the ability to play movies
It's good the only problem is that the gas kind of gets used a little bit fast than other brand cars. In my experience.
How Is the Technology?
Entertainment technology is great in the 2016 Honda Pilot with a standard 5-inch display screen as well as an optional 8-inch touchscreen. Safety technology is also better than average with a standard rearview camera. Optional upgrades include the Honda Sensing Safety Package, which adds automatic braking, collision warnings, as well as lane keeping assistance.
Is the 2016 Honda Pilot a Good Value?
No, the 2016 Honda Pilot is not a good value since it has more expensive mechanical problems than other years. Blue book prices range from $18,325 to $25,475, making it cheaper than a Toyota 4Runner or Subaru Outback. When new, the price range was $30,345 to $46,770. Depreciation is similar to other midsize SUVs, losing 10% of its value per year.
What are the Different Models of the Honda Pilot?
There are five models of the Honda Pilot offered in 2016, from the base LX all the way up to the luxurious Elite.
LX is the entry-level model with:
- 18-Inch Alloy Wheels
- Cloth Seating
- Cruise Control
- 5-Inch Screen
- Rearview Camera
- Bluetooth Connectivity
- 7-Speaker Stereo System
EX is a step up, adding:
- Fog Lights
- LED Running Lights
- Keyless Ignition & Entry
- Remote Start
- Blind Spot Monitoring
- 8-inch Touchscreen Stereo System
EX-L is next in the lineup with:
- Leather Seating
- Sunroof
- Power Tailgate
- Heated Front Seats
- Auto-Dimming Rearview Mirror
Touring has more features such as:
- Automatic Engine Start/Stop
- Honda Sensing Safety Package
- Second Row Sunshades
- Ambient Interior Lighting
- 10-Speaker Stereo System
Elite is the flagship model which adds:
- 20-inch Wheels
- Premium Leather Seating
- Panoramic Sunroof
- Heated Second Row Captain’s Chairs
- LED Headlights
What Engines Come In the Honda Pilot?
The engine found in the 2016 Honda Pilot is a strong 3.5L V6 which makes 280 horsepower while getting up to 23 MPG. Performance is better than average, taking only 6.4 seconds to go from 0-60 MPH. However, the towing capacity is low at up to 3,500 pounds for the front wheel drive model, and 5,000 pounds with the all-wheel drive version.
What Colors Does the Honda Pilot Come In?
How Comfortable Is the Honda Pilot?
The 2016 Honda Pilot is one of the most comfortable midsize SUVs on the market offering seating for 7 to 8 people, depending on the configuration. The seats are extremely nice offering excellent support for longer drives.
Passenger room is fantastic in all three rows with enough legroom for adults. The optional second row captain’s chairs are also very nice for fitting adults in the second row.
How Much Storage Space Does the Honda Pilot Have?
Cargo space is good for a midsize SUV with enough space for 3-4 suitcases behind the third row, 10-12 behind the second, and over 20 with all the seats folded flat.
What Are the Differences Between Years?
The third generation of the Honda Pilot launched in 2016, and is still being made as of 2022.
2014: No major changes.
2015: Introduction of the SE model between EX and EX-L models.
2016: Fully redesigned for the third generation with new styling, transmission, engine, and technology.
2017: Apple CarPlay & Android Auto standard on models with the 8-inch touchscreen stereo.
2018: No major changes.
2019: Small exterior styling changes, standard Honda Sensing safety software, improved stereo system.
2020: New Black Edition model added with more luxurious interior.
How Does the Honda Pilot Compare to the Competition?
The Honda Pilot ranked well when it was new, although a lot of mechanical problems have shown up as it’s aged, making it a year buyers should avoid.
The Toyota Highlander is another midsize SUV which costs around $2,000 more. Reliability ratings are better on the Toyota Highlander, while the Honda Pilot has more room in its third row to easily fit taller adults. We recommend the Toyota Highlander for 2016 since there are fewer expensive problems reported.
The Acura MDX is a more luxurious midsize SUV which costs $1,500 more. Both the Acura MDX and Honda Pilot are built on the same platform, while technology and interior materials are nicer in the Acura MDX. We recommend staying away from both models for 2016 since they have the same engine and transmission problems.
Do Owners Recommend the Honda Pilot?
Yes. It is very good. It fits my large family and driving needs. It has many extras that my whole family loves.
Yes so far has been a good vehicle it is just a lot on gas if I do not use the green saver button then I use lots of gas.
Yes it is a good SUV to drive, it has enough space whether it is to lift people or supplies. And its average on fuel consumption.
Very much so. On my second pilot and wouldn't drive any other SUV. Lots of room, good gas mileage, smooth ride. Has the right amount of controls that do not overwhelm you. Love the heated seats, and side window defrost along with being able to multi control heat and cool.
This vehicle potentially saved my life. The safety features are wonderful and I am so grateful for the auto brake sensor that braked the car before I had the chance to. There are also airbags throughout the vehicle. Though I am impressed with the gas mileage this SUV gets it did take a few weeks to adjust to the nine speed transmission. I now love it. This is a solid car with great features like push button start/stop and touch screen system. I highly recommend this vehicle.
For the most part. It has 127,000 miles on it so far. Had an engine issue about 10,000 miles ago. But overall, it is a good, sturdy vehicle.
I love my pilot. It is an elite and I love the captain's chairs. I had a CR-V prior to this car and I had it for 11 years. T is a huge reason for getting another Honda plus we needed an additional seat since we went from 3 to 4 grandkids and 6 peeps wouldn't fit in the CR-V
Yes the Honda Pilot 2016 is a very good vehicle. I would recommend it to other people for sure. Quality is good