Toyota RAV4’s Worst Years & Years to Avoid Include 2009’s 15 Recalls Over Unintended Acceleration, Risk of Fire

Drew Blankenship
Nov 16, 2021

Toyota is renowned for reliability, but the RAV4 has seen its share of issues in its 27 years of production. From airbags not deploying to complaints of vehicles catching fire, we review the problems associated with the popular compact SUV.

2020 Toyota RAV4 - Photos by Toyota

Key Points

  • Since its U.S. debut in 1996, the Toyota RAV4 has built a reputation for dependability. But as time went on, the list of RAV4 recalls and complaints grew to 14 recalls and almost 1,000 complaints in 2007, addressing issues like faulty seat belts and airbags not deploying.
  • The RAV4’s 2006 redesign faced 11 recalls and problems with unintended acceleration and power-window wiring that could lead to an electrical fire.
  • More recent model years also have serious safety issues, with the 2019 RAV4 racking up seven recalls and over 400 complaints.
  • The 2009 model has racked up the most recalls of any RAV4 ever made–a total of 15–in addition to three investigations and over 300 complaints with the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. Some of the recalls are minor, such as mislabeled load stickers, while others are serious safety concerns that include unintended acceleration, risk of fire, and faulty seat belts.

2007 Toyota RAV4 - Photos by Toyota

RAV4’s 2006 Redesign Brought 11 Recalls and Many Problems, Like Unreliable Airbags and Acceleration Issues

Toyota’s 2006 RAV4 has some of the model’s most serious safety issues that are covered in 11 recalls for things like rear suspension arm corrosion, airbag deployment problems, and power-window wiring that could lead to an electrical fire. Many of these problems, and more, continued through 2010, when the carmaker redesigned the RAV4 once again.

The 2007 Toyota RAV4 tacked on three additional recalls for a total of 14, including issues with the seat belts not locking properly, and a sticky accelerator pedal. Outside of the recalls, this generation RAV4 also presented a number of other issues.

Excessive oil consumption is commonly reported for the 2007 RAV4, with some consumers reporting their vehicle using a full quart of oil in just a few hundred miles. There are some horror stories from RAV4 owners when it comes to airbags and acceleration issues as well.

One consumer reports that the vehicle propelled forward as they hit the brakes in their driveway, causing them to crash into their home. Others were reportedly launched into busy intersections or lost control of the car on the highway.

2013 Toyota Rav4 - Photos by Toyota

Battery Fires and Cracking Sunroofs Marred RAV4’s Third-generation, with the 2012 Model Receiving Six Recalls

The 2012 RAV4 introduced a number of new problems, and racked up six recalls, covering light problems like incorrect load labels and inoperative windshield wipers. The most serious recall concerns a software issue that may result in a possible loss of drive power that could increase the risk of a crash.

Multiple reports have been filed about the 2013 model catching fire due to a battery issue. A majority of the fires occurred while driving, with four taking place with the ignition off. Drivers experienced stalling prior to the fire in half of the instances where the vehicle was in motion. The 12-volt battery was identified as the area of origin in a majority of the incidents reviewed.

In one instance, an owner’s house reportedly burnt down due to the battery in the RAV4 catching fire inside his garage. An open investigation over the issue was launched in February 2021.

Peeling Blizzard Pearl Paint on 2013 RAV4 Proves to be an Unsightly Problem

Although not nearly as serious or dangerous of a problem as the battery fires, the 2013 Toyota RAV4 does have a pervasive problem of owners reporting that the paint on their vehicle began to bubble and crack. Judging from the many individual NHTSA complaints, the paint issue seems to be occurring specifically with the white paint.

“The Blizzard Pearl paint is peeling between the windshield and the sunroof, coming off in large pieces the size of a silver dollar,” reports one 2013 Toyota RAV4 owner in the NHTSA complaints. “Paint blisters first then just falls off the roof of the car. …It has been parked in the same places that my prior Toyotas, and this problem has never occurred before.”

2009 Toyota RAV4 - Photo by Toyota

2009 Tops the List for Worst Years of the Toyota RAV4, with More Risk of Electrical Fires and Sticky Accelerator Pedals

If you go by the numbers, 2009 is the worst year for the Toyota RAV4. The 2009 RAV4 has racked up a total of 15 recalls, three investigations, and over 300 complaints with the NHTSA. In fact, 2009 has the most recalls of any RAV4 ever made. Some of the recalls are minor, such as mislabeled load stickers, while others are serious safety concerns.

A few of the more dangerous recalls for the 2009 Toyota RAV4 involve unintended acceleration, risk of fire, and the seat belts not working properly during an accident. Numerous consumer complaints with the NHTSA stated that their RAV4 would accelerate on its own.

In some cases, the throttle input was enough to overpower the brakes and resulted in an accident. With mounting complaints from consumers and open investigations by the NHTSA, Toyota was forced to recall over two million of their vehicles for a sticky accelerator pedal.

Power Window’s Faulty Electrical Components May Cause a Short Circuit that Can Result in a Fire

Another serious recall on the 2009 RAV4 is the fire risk associated with the electrical components inside the power window track. The window track uses grease to ensure smooth operation, but over time, the grease could dry, allowing moisture and debris to build up, causing the switch to short circuit.

When this happens, the master power window switch melts and, in some cases, can result in a vehicle fire. The power window switch melting was such a big problem for Toyota that the automaker had to issue two recalls: one in 2012 affecting two and a half million vehicles, and the second recall in 2015 that added almost another two million Toyotas to the list.

Despite Some Problems and Recalls, is the Toyota RAV4 a Reliable Vehicle?

In truth, the Toyota RAV4 may have left its best days behind. More recent models are riddled with serious safety issues that Toyota seems lackadaisical about fixing. If you’re interested in purchasing a RAV4, shoot for an older, more reliable model, or be sure what you’re buying is still under warranty. Chances are, you’ll need it.

Photos: Toyota

Frequently Asked Questions

By Josh Barrett | Nov 16, 2021

Does the Toyota RAV4 Have a Lot of Transmission Problems?

The 2002 RAV4 has a lot of transmission problems, like issues shifting, jerking, hesitating, or total transmission failure, none of which are addressed by recalls. Newer models do not have many transmission faults, besides a few scattered incidents of jumping/slipping gears and/or grinding sounds.

Which Year Toyota RAV4 is Best?

A 2018 Toyota RAV4 is likely the best year ever built for the model. Not only does it have just two recalls and a scarce 145 registered complaints, but most are still covered by their powertrain warranty. To cut costs, a 2016 RAV4 is also considered to be one of the best years and is similarly less problematic.

Owner Reviews

accountCircle Sean on October 20, 2021
Transmission problems 2019 Rav4 Trail
What I absolutely hate about my rav4 Trail. The ongoing transmission problem. When the car is warm it makes a loud bussing/vibrating noise...this happens around 40 km an hour and up to around 60. It continues to make the noises when you speed up and slow down. (2) the car had a bad rattling sound coming from the gear shifter. It turns out that the bolts holding it in were loose. (3) the rav lunges forward on it's own from a complete stop and sends you flying bach. And when stopping sometimes as it's shifting down it almost feels like it's locking up.
accountCircle elaine mckeown on November 9, 2021
Transfer case noise in 2019 Rav4
Bought this car brand new...within2 weeks, noticed a "groaning" type of noise when driven in eco mode. Turns out it is issues with the transfer case. According to toyota canada there is an issue with the transfer case on this model and they are currently working on a solution. Very frustrating that one purchases a new vehicle only to have issue with it.
accountCircle Melissa W on November 13, 2021
The problems with my 2006 Rav4
The vehicle has had lots of recalls. It feels like every time I turn around that I am getting another recall notice in the mail. The drivers side visor is broken and will fall in my face while I'm driving. Also the thermostat knob is broken and won't fully turn to the vent only setting.
accountCircle Margaret W on October 25, 2021
2006 Rav4 with a few problems.
I have a few problems with how it runs. There is a hole in the muffler as well as an exhaust leak into the car. I do not know how common this is in other RAV4s, but these are a few of the problems I am dealing with. My RAV4 does not have good acceleration, which can be frustrating.
accountCircle KAY A on November 15, 2021
2012 Toyota rav4 common problems.
Excessive oil consumption between oil changes, even to the extent of the engine oil warning light displayed on the multi-function display. The typical problems from this rav4 generation include water pump leaks, exhaust leaks due to rust, a clunking noise from the steering column.
accountCircle Geoffrey P on October 21, 2021
2009 Rav4 engine lights come on for no reason
The engine lights come on often, but I cannot detect a problem. I have given it to a mechanic but he does not find anything wrong with it, so I drive the car and the lights go off for a while and then come on much later, and I go through the same ritual.
accountCircle Sierra C on October 21, 2021
Every time I fix one thing on the 2009 Rav4, something else goes wrong.
The air went out about 4 months after purchasing it used and needed a new compressor. There are a lot of problems with my power steering. The wiring is very faulty, causing lights to come on and stay on even when there are no problems.
accountCircle Shawn Fauvelle on November 14, 2021
Serious Transmission/Transfer Case Problem 2019 Rav4
Have a 2019 RAV4 Trail Edition barely 3 months old, experiencing noise and rough shifting/jerky motion off start. Took it into the dealer Toyota is apparently aware of a problem with the transfer case and currently has no fix.
accountCircle Shirley Smith Camus, Texas on October 16, 2021
Have a 2007 Toyota Limited, got it second hand from car broker with 76,000 miles.
Love the car but not the oil problem, never leave home without a quart of oil. Now it has developed a "clunking noise" in the steering column. Just wish Toyota would do a recall on this problem. I can't afford a $2,000 bill.
accountCircle Cassidy G on November 12, 2021
Used 2007 RAV4: disappointing reliability.
In the first 3 months of ownership I have had significant problems with it: sunroof shattered, needed a new o2 sensor, and the coolant pipe came loose, causing all the coolant to leak out and the engine to overheat.
accountCircle Casey D on November 10, 2021
A few issues mostly due to age of my 2006 Rav4
Have several issues with struts. The engine is loud compared to many vehicles. Does not speed up very well. Have had to put a lot of money into it, but it is old. The ac smells weird when not used for awhile.
accountCircle Sylvia C on October 18, 2021
The problems with my 2007 rav4.
Have had problems with engine burning oil. Had the brakes just go out one day. Would not buy another one just because of the issues I've had and Toyota does nothing for it.
accountCircle Kristen S on November 12, 2021
2006 RAV4. My issues
One of the O2 sensors broke a few months ago and that was a bit expensive to get repaired. And a few weeks ago my alternator broke, which then drained my battery.
accountCircle Janet Wilkinson on October 28, 2021
2019 RAV4 -Rethinking Next Purchase
It makes a terrible noise when decelerating and accelerating, moos like a cow, has been going on for 10 months and they are unable to figure it out.
accountCircle Annie L on October 25, 2021
Brake issues with my 2012 Rav4
Love my car but it has a lot of problems with the brakes. Always having to get them fixed and always making weird noises.
accountCircle Catherine D on November 16, 2021
Air conditioning has been my only issue
The only issue I have ever had is with the air conditioning which I'm not sure if this happens with other RAV4s.
accountCircle Kristen R on October 16, 2021
My 2006 Rav4 engine had to be replaced
A few years back I had an issue with oil consumption, but Toyota replaces the engine for free.
accountCircle K maitro on November 4, 2021
Serious Battery/Electrical Issues 2019 rav4
My 2019 rav4 Limited has been in the shop 5 times in the past 4 months for battery issues.
accountCircle Dennis K on October 24, 2021
Issue with sensors on my 2006 Rav4
One of the sensors needs to be replaced. And this is the second time that has happened.
accountCircle Ronald M on October 31, 2021
2007 Rav4 had a coolant leak issue
Only issue I have had is a coolant leak that did not involve the water pump.
accountCircle Chan F on October 14, 2021
2013 Toyota RAV4 shakes due to transmission
The only issue is the drive is a bit shaky, maybe a transmission issue.
accountCircle Jeremiah T on October 15, 2021
100,000 miles and a bad alternator on my 2007 Rav4
I have only had one minor problem with my rav4's alternator going bad.
accountCircle susan m on October 17, 2021
2009 Rav4 has had several recalls that have been very inconvenient.
It has had several recall and repaired by Toyota free of cost.
accountCircle Linda W on October 31, 2021
Knocking noise coming from engine of my 2009 Rav4
It has issues with the rear suspension and knocking noise.
avatar Drew Blankenship
Drew Blankenship is a former Porsche technician with nearly 15 years of experience. Born in North Carolina, the heart of NASCAR country, he grew up building and racing cars before later working for a local import tuning shop, Driven Performance. Fueled by long nights in the garage and some engine-tuning wizardry from the shop’s owner, by his 20s Drew was outrunning sport bikes in a 1992 Honda Civic hatchback with a power-to-weight ratio rivaling a Bugatti Veyron. He continued upgrading and repairing Japanese cars until a chance meeting with a Porsche master technician at Rezoom, a Porsche specialist shop in Tennessee. He was taken under the wing of a veteran Porsche driving instructor and learned everything to know about air-cooled Porsches. Today, he shares his mechanical knowledge on several popular auto websites, including Youcanic and Vehicle History.
  • Articles
  • chevronRightAlternative
  • Toyota RAV4’s Worst Years & Years to Avoid Include 2009’s 15 Recalls Over Unintended Acceleration, Risk of Fire