2011 Toyota Tacoma Problems Cover Possible Fire Hazards, Including from Faulty Wiring in the Seat Heaters

Though it has been hit with nine recalls over safety issues, the 2011 Toyota Tacoma is still quite reliable, and complaints not involving recalls are few. But the annual maintenance cost is a bit high.

2011 Toyota Tacoma - Photo by Toyota

Key Points

  • 2011 Toyota Tacomas are prone to fire from the factory, with one-third of its nine NHTSA recalls involving fire hazards, including one over faulty wiring in the seat heaters.
  • Loose seat belts and faulty seat belt sensors put Tacoma passengers at risk of injury or death in the event of a crash.
  • The transmission on higher-mileage 2011 Tacomas may be susceptible to malfunctioning.
  • Running lights in the headlight assembly may burn so hot that melt the lenses of the headlight assembly.
  • Annual repair costs of the Tacoma are relatively high, but they are worth the price given the Tacoma’s track record as a long-lasting vehicle.

2011 Toyota Tacoma - Photo by Toyota

Bad Wiring and Other Fire Risks Headline Recalls for the 2011 Toyota Tacoma Pickup Truck

Toyota’s Tacoma is one of the most reliable pickup trucks on the market, with some having driven over a million miles. The 2011 Toyota Tacoma is no exception to this history, but it’s not without its faults either.

Most notable among the 2011 Tacoma’s nine recalls is an issue where the leaf spring rear suspension may break and possibly puncture the gas tank. The broken suspension could lead to a vehicle stall or the possibility of a fire.

Also two National Highway Traffic Safety Administration recalls concern faulty wiring in the seat heaters that could short circuit and cause a fire.

2011 Toyota Tacoma - Photo by Toyota

2011 Toyota Tacoma’s Seat Sensors May Malfunction, Preventing Airbags from Deploying

Toyota’s occupant classification system is essentially a weight sensor meant to communicate to the vehicle whether or not there is a passenger located in a seat. If there is not, the airbags will not deploy in a crash.

In a 2013 recall for the 2011 Toyota Tacoma, it was reported that some occupant classification systems may be miscalibrated and thus are unreliable in the event of an accident. The solution is a recalibration via a dealership.

2011 Toyota Tacoma - Photo by Toyota

Hood Scoops and Seat Belts on the 2011 Tacoma are Prone to Loosening

In a recall issued in 2017, it was found that some 2011 Toyota Tacoma’s hood scoops were susceptible to loosening.

In the event of this happening, the hood scoop may fly upward and obscure the driver’s vision or land on the road, increasing the risk of an accident.

Further, seat belt fixture screws may loosen, as reported in a 2013 recall, possibly coming detached.

If a crash occurs under these conditions, vehicle occupants may not be restrained by the seat belts, increasing the likelihood of injury.

2011 Toyota Tacoma - Photo by Toyota

2011 Tacoma’s Other Issues are Few, but Transmissions are Susceptible to Problems at High Mileages

Complaints for the 2011 Toyota Tacoma that do not relate to recalls are relatively few.

There are only 163 consumer complaints registered with the NHTSA. The majority concern the suspension and likely have been addressed in recalls.

Chief among the complaints for the 2011 Tacoma are reports that the automatic transmission loses its ability to shift when the truck reaches high miles.

The problem typically stems from improperly adjusted throttle position sensors or broken shift solenoids.

Another widely-reported complaint is that the running lights of the Tacoma are so hot when lit that they may melt or crack the lenses of the headlights.

Owners may have to replace the headlight assembly, which is not costly, but still an annoyance.

2011 Toyota Tacoma - Photo by Toyota

The 2011 Tacoma is as Dependable as Ever, and Addressing Any Issues Early Will Ensure a Long Life for the Toyota Pickup Truck

Annual maintenance costs for the 2011 Toyota Tacoma average around $839. While this is a little higher than some competitors, most of the 2011 Tacoma’s rivals are not be expected to surpass 300,000 miles in their lifetime.

So, despite some notable problems that are likely already handled via recalls, the Tacoma’s famous durability outweighs the risks associated with the 2011 model.

Toyota is great at addressing recalls quickly, and its reputation for building vehicles with impressive longevity persists through the challenges some model years face.

Photos: Toyota

Frequently Asked Questions

By Stephanie Stephan | Apr 14, 2022

Is the 2011 Toyota Tacoma Reliable?

The 2011 Toyota Tacoma was given a “poor” reliability rating of two out of five by J.D. Power but owners report high satisfaction with the 2011 Tacoma giving it 4.5 out of five stars on Edmunds and 4.7/5 stars for dependability on Cars.com. Problems include recalls for faulty leaf springs that can puncture the fuel tank, and seat wiring that shorts and causes fires.

What Common Problems Do Toyota Tacomas Have?

The Tacoma’s transmission is known to experience shifting errors beginning at 125,000 miles in 1995-2015 models due to throttle position sensor or shift solenoid failure. Cracked parking light lenses, front ball joint wear, and contamination of the MAF sensor that causes rough idling and sluggish acceleration are also common.

Owner Reviews

accountCircle Brady F on July 23, 2021
Good all-around city truck.
Have had issues with my transmission getting stuck in some gears as I increase and decrease my speed at a slower rate. My tire pressure light has been on for a couple of months but all of my tires are fully inflated and have no holes. The size of the extended cab is perfect for my long legs and arms.
accountCircle Megan H on September 5, 2021
Acceleration Issues
The only issues I have with it are that it is too big of a vehicle for my personal preference and it does not accelerate as quickly as a smaller car would. It has pretty good gas mileage and I use it daily and have not had any serious problems with it.
avatar Warren Stoddard II
Warren Stoddard II is an avid enthusiast of vintage vehicles. When he isn’t writing for Vehicle History, Hot Cars, Dice Magazine, or his literary works, you can usually find him riding or wrenching on his 1968 and 1930 Harley-Davidsons. When the weather is bad, he takes his ’67 Dodge D100. Following his graduation from Texas State University in 2018, Warren’s writing has been featured in The Antonym, Into the Void, and numerous publications around the globe, where they have received several honors. He is the author of the novella No Birds in Yesterday, and the short-story collection A Good Place on the Banks of the Euphrates.
  • Articles
  • chevronRightAlternative
  • 2011 Toyota Tacoma Problems Cover Possible Fire Hazards, Including from Faulty Wiring in the Seat Heaters