Best and Worst Years for the Nissan Pathfinder Include Safety Awards and a Lawsuit

Khris Bharath
Oct 4, 2021

The Nissan Pathfinder remains a popular mid-size SUV equipped with award-winning safety features. However, not all model years were created equal, with some racking up over 2,000 complaints and a lawsuit.

2017 Nissan Pathfinder - Photo by Nissan

Key Points

  • The 2018 and 2019 model years of the Nissan Pathfinder offer the best blend of performance, tech, and comfort.
  • The 2005 model year is by far the worst in terms of complaints and overall recalls.
  • Owners of the 2013 model year reported issues with the CVT, which resulted in a class-action lawsuit.

Nissan Pathfinder’s Best Years Include Major Safety Upgrade in 2018, Parents Magazine Award in 2019

Debuting in 1986, the Nissan Pathfinder has been on the market for over 35 years. The popular family SUV, which has its roots in a compact pick-up truck, is now in its fifth generation for the 2022 model year. The sport utility vehicle’s earlier generations were tough-looking, boxy, and rugged, with a robust ladder-frame chassis. However, from 2013 onward, the Pathfinder went the crossover route, with a unibody construction. Both body styles have their merits and drawbacks.

2019 Nissan Pathfinder - Photo by Nissan

2019 Pathfinder’s Tech & Safety Features Led Parents to Name it ‘Best Three-row SUV’

The 2019 Nissan Pathfinder, with its array of advanced safety and driver assistance features, was named to the Best Three-Row SUVs category in Parents Magazine’s list of “10 Best Family Cars of 2019.” Pathfinder was noted specifically for its Intelligent Around View Monitor camera technology, which pairs with other available features that focus on the area around the vehicle, including Blind Spot Warning and Predictive Forward Collision Warning and can warn you of possible hazards. Also of note is the rear door alarm, which detects if a rear door is opened prior to driving. And if it is not opened again at the end of the trip, the system can remind customers that something might be left in the rear seat.

2018 Nissan Pathfinder - Photo by Nissan

2018 Pathfinder Got a Major Safety Feature Added as Standard

In 2017, Nissan announced that it was making Automatic Emergency Braking standard on one million vehicles sold in the U.S. for model year 2018, including the Pathfinder. In essence, the addition of the standard AEB makes an already safe and reliable vehicle even safer.

AEB (previously known as Forward Emergency Braking) uses radar technology to monitor a vehicle’s proximity to the car ahead, giving the driver audible and visual display warnings to help him reduce the vehicle’s speed if a potential front collision is detected. If the driver fails to respond, the AEB system can apply the brakes.

According to National Highway Traffic Safety Administration data, one-third of all police-reported crashes involve a rear-end collision (2013 study). The NHTSA also reports that systems such as AEB can help reduce injury by as much as 35% (2015 report).

2013 Nissan Pathfinder - Photo by Nissan

Nissan Pathfinder’s Worst Years Include Highest Recalls in 2013, Lawsuit over Shaky CVTs

The 2013 Nissan Pathfinder had one of the model’s highest recall rates. There were 10 in total, with the most serious involving the ABS braking system, which could increase stopping distance rather than shorten it, raising the risk of a crash. This recall affected over 151,000 2013 and 2014 Nissan Pathfinders.

Another major recall was caused by the loss of transmission fluid in models equipped with a CVT, resulting in transmission failure. Due to weak clamping force, the oil cooler hose could detach, leaking fluid. The recall affected just over 3,000 2013 Nissan Pathfinders.

The continuously variable transmission problem is also part of a class-action lawsuit affecting model year 2013 and 2014 Pathfinder SUVs and alleging that the CVT shakes excessively during acceleration between 15 and 30 miles per hour.

In a 2016 recall, nearly 3.3 million Nissan vehicles, including the 2013-2017 Pathfinder, had issues with the occupant seat sensor. It incorrectly identified a passenger seat as empty, although it was occupied. This prevented the airbag from deploying, increasing the chances of injury in the event of an accident.

2005 Nissan Pathfinder

2005 Pathfinder Garnered 2,000 Complaints, Class Action Lawsuit

The 2005 Nissan Pathfinder makes our “worst year” list not because of its four relatively light recall problems, but because of its over 2,000 complaints registered with the NHTSA and Car Complaints. The majority of this overload of negative feedback centers on the transmission. Engine and fuel system problems round out the top three most reported complaints.

Although, the 2005 model’s seatbelts were also an issue of contention. While the rest of the feedback focuses on less vital issues like interior and exterior accessories, the three main complaints are serious enough to warrant deeper research and careful consideration when it comes to the Pathfinder’s 2005 model year.

The biggest transmission problem that racked up over 400 complaints concerns 2005-2007 Pathfinders, which may have a defective radiator where a coolant leak may cause transmission failure around 90,000 miles. The repair can be costly, edging upwards of $3,500.

The 2005 Nissan Pathfinder also logged in four official recalls, with the most significant being a problematic crash zone sensor.

2022 Nissan Pathfinder - Photo by Nissan

Despite Some Bad Years, is the Pathfinder a Decent SUV?

Although, the Pathfinder is reasonably affordable to run and maintain, certain model years are best av0ided in favor of more reliable model years. The overall average annual maintenance and repair cost of a Nissan Pathfinder is around $550, according to Repair Pal.

The boxy style that Pathfinder fans have known and loved is now finally back with the 2022 model year. The current Pathfinder’s robust styling is now paired with car-like agility. It is a significant update, because the 2022 Nissan Pathfinder finally has new technology and off-road hardware to compete with rivals.

However, if you can live with slightly dated styling, a used Nissan Pathfinder is a fantastic used purchase. It would be a smart idea to look into a Nissan Certified Pre-owned vehicle, which undergoes a 167-point inspection.

Photos: Nissan

Owner Reviews

accountCircle Jason on September 9, 2022
My 1999 Pathfinder, the little engine that could...
After 10+ years of ownership, my brother gave me his '99 Pathfinder. It's been three years since I took ownership and with 248,672 miles on her (side note: my brother purchased it while stationed in Maryland then drove it home to Los Angeles). Aside fron oil changes and brakes,my brother never made any repairs or serviced the vehicle. I on the other hand, have replaced the front strut assembly, rear shocks, front axles, rack and pinion bushings, sway bar bushings, souter tie rods, front and rear sway bar links, alternator, battery, harmonic balancer (crankshaft pulley), water pump, timing belt tensioner pulley, timing belt and remaining drive belts. Oh and the fuel pump. All this cost me around $680 thanks to Carparts dot com, Partsgeek dot com, and Amazon. Also a big thank you to both Eric the Car Guy (your expertise will be missed sir, enjoy your retirement. Check him out on youtube for hundred of repair videos, and also the guys at 1A Auto for their detailed how to videos on you tube as well. These two channels saves me Thousands in labor costs. So almost 250,000 miles and $700 worth of parts and i can say this Pathfinder runs like she's ready for another 250,000 miles. Thanks for reading.
accountCircle Lee W on October 5, 2021
2018 Nissan pathfinder review.
This car is really great in winter conditions I have never been stuck in the snow. It easily switches to four wheel drive. And also has a traction button for going down steep inclines. The seats are comfortable and access to the third row is easy. However the third row seats are very small and cramped only big enough for a small child. And there is hardly any trunk space for storage. The seats do fold down nicely for moving. Performance wise has enough get up and go being a v6 and with regular maintenance I have had zero engine issues. The touch screen controls are very user friendly and easy to use. The sound system is pretty good as well considering its does not have a Bose sound package or anything like that. Style of the car is great appealing on the outside and the rims are sleek and sporty.
accountCircle Dawn C on October 5, 2021
I love my 2019 Nissan Pathfinder!
My 2019 Nissan Pathfinder is the best vehicle I have owned. I have the platinum trim which is equipped with all the luxury features. It is equipped with electronic heated leather seats that are super comfortable and adjust with ease. You can also turn the seat temperature to cool in the summer months. The steering wheel to the gear shifter are coated with soft leather trim. The touch screen media and navigation screen is easy to follow and designed for easy use by the driver. The vehicle has third row seating and is nice and roomy. The headrests are equipped with DVD players which are great for the kids on long road trips, keeps them nice and entertained. Overall I have had no problems with this vehicle, it drives super smooth and handles great.
accountCircle Tim Scott on October 6, 2021
2013 Pathfinder Transmission Issues
Transmission was recalled for replacement 12/2016. We were assured the issue with the transmission was reengineered and should not experience the slipping of CVT belt again. Sorry to report this is not true, once again, we have exactly the same slippage problem. This transmission is poorly engineered and Nissan will not assist with the repair of the second transmission. I will admit we drive a lot, but, we do not abuse our car.
accountCircle Katlyn M on October 4, 2021
It has great safety features, plenty of room, and looks super stylish.
My 2018, Nissan pathfinder is a perfect fit for my growing family. We love the 3rd row seat option! It gives us tons more room for our huge dog in the back or for our trips to the grocery store. The seats are so simple and pretty much effortless to fold down and up. So far we've had no issues with the vehicle at all. It's perfect for family vacation trips where everyone has plenty of room and can sit in comfort as well.
accountCircle Laci on October 4, 2021
Unreliable 2013 Pathfinder
I’ve owned Nissans for years. Would never buy another one. Air conditioning went out after 3 years. Transmission went out after 5 years. Visors are extremely poor design. Had them replaced under warranty, then refused to use the new ones, but they STILL broke. They fall down and obstruct view. It is roomy, and gets decent gas mileage- but unless you are a mechanic, I’d avoid this car.
accountCircle Melissa on December 21, 2023
2014 Pathfinder
We bought a used 2014 Pathfinder, that had been a rental, with only 32k miles on it. Here we are years later with over 220k miles on it and it finally just broke. I love this car so much because it was really dependable, and I can’t find anything that I like as well as this car. I’m considering just fixing the transmission to keep it because this car is so reliable.
accountCircle Linda S on October 4, 2021
2019 Nissan pathfinder- luxury vehicle with a trucks hauling power.
The pathfinder is very comfortable in the city and on long rides (6+ hrs). We have had no problems with this vehicle at all, and love the safety features, especially when on the highway, with the assist of cameras, and when parking. We also use it to tow a utility trailer, atv, and whatever else we need to. I would buy this again in a heartbeat.
accountCircle Liz G on October 5, 2021
2013 Pathfinder: Faulty transmissions and parts coming off the line!
Several recalls on airbags, there were electrical and transmission problems until it went out and Nissan refused to do anything about it. There was a recall campaign on the same year as mine and during the same time manufacturing but Nissan said my vehicle wasn't apart of the campaign. Corporate refused to fix my problem.
accountCircle Jessica K on October 4, 2021
2013 Pathfinder transmission and other problems
It is comfortable to drive and has many added features. But, I have already replaced transmission, about to replace the fan motor and replaced door handles and again need replacing in the rear and it leaks tremendously. The seals everywhere have come loose and around the sunroof and moonroof they are loose again.
accountCircle Stacy on October 4, 2021
2013 Pathfinder CVT transmission problems.
We bought it new off the lot and have had to take it in numerous times for transmission problems. CVT transmission shakes when taking off. I found out there was a class action lawsuit filed on 2013 Nissan with CVT transmission. They’ve fixed it several times but every so often it shakes when I take off.
accountCircle Hope C on October 5, 2021
It drives amazing, it has a ton of safety features.
My 2018 Nissan pathfinder sl midnight edition, is the best car I have ever owned, it is comfortable to drive and has all the features I love. Nissan really pays attention to details. It is very roomy for my family of 4 with plenty of cargo space in the rear. The fuel mileage is decent for a crossover.
accountCircle Sarah G on October 5, 2021
2019 Nissan pathfinder great car for a family!
I love this vehicle. It is a perfect family car with a lot of space for everyone. The third row seat is really helpful and the trunk storage when the third row is laid down is great. It is got push button start, Bluetooth, keyless entry, great mpg and remote start up, which is great for cold mornings.
accountCircle LaShonda B on October 6, 2021
Buyer beware of 2013 Pathfinder lemon. Expensive vehicle to maintain.
One month after purchase(2014), the transmission had to be replaced. The transmission had to be replaced again in 2019. Countless amount of costly repairs. I will never even consider purchasing another Nissan again. The only positive feature is that the vehicle is spacious.
accountCircle Melissa S on October 6, 2021
2013 Nissan Pathfinder review.
Transmission failure very common, constantly replacing parts, transfer case replaced. Very spacious, seats 7 comfortably, very good in the snow, good gas mileage. Third row folds down leaving plenty of space for storage. Full size spare tire instead of donut.
accountCircle Tabatha R on October 6, 2021
Review of my 2018 pathfinder sv.
I love the 2018 Nissan pathfinder. It drives really smooth. I do wish the gas mileage was a little better. The seats are very comfortable. The third row is very accessible to get to. It is very roomy and I have been able to load a bunch of stuff in the back.
accountCircle Jane R on October 5, 2021
2013 Pathfinder on it's third transmission.
It is very comfortable and spacious. I have had to replace two transmissions in seven years as there seems to be a problem with that years transmissions. Other than that, the performance is great and we have driven many long journeys in this car.
accountCircle Lindsey S on October 4, 2021
Do not buy 2005 Pathfinder! It will just break down and Nissan should give a replacement for anyone who owns it.
It breaks down all the time. It has a problem with the transmission. We have already replaced the transmission and it is broken again. It always has weird sensor problems as well. All in all it is a horrible car that I wish I had never bought.
accountCircle Chris P on October 6, 2021
Super size 2005 Pathfinder
My 4 wheel drive shaft snapped and cracked my transmission. So now my transmission fluid leaks out and I'm using 3 quarts a day just to go to work and home. Other than that it is an awesome overall SUV. Seats 8 and has a luggage rack on top.
accountCircle David on October 6, 2021
2013 Pathfinder Transmission Failure
Very nice and comfortable except for the fact that mine has only 27k miles and the transmission went out already. Also not so great with families more than 5 people, very little leg room on the back and hard to get to.
accountCircle Lillie Smith on October 6, 2021
Computer plus engine problems with 2005 Pathfinder
I thought when I bought my pathfinder it would be very dependable,. 130,000 miles, $2,600 for computer/labor. 16k, miles need to replace the engine. Elderly person , drives less than 15k miles per year.
accountCircle Kelly H on October 6, 2021
2005 Pathfinder has a transmission that is not powerful enough for the vehicle.
The pathfinder is known for issues with its catalytic converter as well as maintaining proper oil pressure and issues with AC, all of which we have experienced. It has become a complete money pit.
accountCircle Carol F on October 5, 2021
2013 Pathfinder transmission had problems but overall drives good.
I love that it has a 3rd row for seating. It drives really nice. I did not like that it has had transmission problems.
accountCircle Jill B on October 5, 2021
Transmission replacement was only downside of 2013 Pathfinder
The only problem I have had with this vehicle was having to replace the transmission. Everything else has been great!
accountCircle Meg B on October 4, 2021
2005 Pathfinder has some problems including rust
It's great in the snow. It is easy to drive. It has constant small glitches/problems. It is starting to rust out.
accountCircle Mary R on October 6, 2021
2013 Pathfinder has had some issues.
Always has transmission troubles. Replaced it and still does not run right. It has too many mechanical issues.
accountCircle Christine T on October 4, 2021
2013 Pathfinder prices are fair and coverage is good with the company.
I appreciated no hassle with warranty when I had to replace the transmission.
avatar Khris Bharath
As with any gearhead, the car bug bit Khris early on. He grew up watching shows like Pimp My Ride, OverHaulin, and Top Gear. His admiration of cars led Khris to pursue a degree in Mechanical Engineering, where he worked on a hydrogen fuel cell and participated in a Baja build and several Local Auto Quizzes, where he showcased his vast knowledge of cars. He is also a classic car aficionado and loves Formula One. He diligently makes time to tune in for the Grand Prix on Sundays.
  • Articles
  • chevronRightAlternative
  • Best and Worst Years for the Nissan Pathfinder Include Safety Awards and a Lawsuit