Honda Pilot Transmission Problems Worth Knowing Of

Sandy B
Jan 26, 2021

When new vehicles are released, manufacturers often have invested a significant amount of time and money into ensuring their stability and safety. Problems happen with all vehicles, including the Honda Pilot. You should know about the big ones, like transmission problems, if you plan to buy this vehicle.

Are there significant Honda Pilot transmission problems?

Yes, there have been some transmission problems with the Honda Pilot, including:

  • Transmission jerking
  • Transmission slips and jerks
  • Total transmission failures
  • Lurching forward in “Park”
  • Transmission fluid leaks

 2021 Honda Pilot 4dr All-wheel Drive LX 1300-OEM Exterior 3/4 Front Left-Facing Primary

These are some significant problems with the Honda Pilot that you should know about before you buy. We’ll break down some of these big problems here. It is also wise to take a closer look at your Vehicle History before you invest.

Transmission Jerking

This is by far one of the most common complaints about the transmission in the modern Honda Pilot. In older models, such as those from 2003 to 2005, other concerns exist. Yet, a large number of consumers have noted problems with the transmission jerking or engaging in difficult movements.

The jerking movements happen when the vehicle is changing gears. It can be so significant that a person will physically move as a result.

Others report the transmission jerking when they are driving it. Some reported the problem began to happen once at around 5,000 miles, while others reported it much later than this. The key here is that the jerking movement is significant and can indicate a problem with the shifting process.

Honda has not issued a recall on these specific concerns. However, the 2019 and 2018 model years tend to have a lot of reports for this problem.

Transmission Slips and Jerks

Some drivers noted the transmission slipping. This often accompanies claims of a jerking movement as well. Some drivers report that it sounds like a grinding noise is coming from the transmission when it does this. It may not move right away, and then, when it does, it jerks the driver.

The slipping problem can happen at high speeds as well. When the driver depresses the gas pedal, the vehicle does not accelerate as it should. Drivers also report they can feel when the car is moving from one gear to the next, especially at higher speeds.

Transmission slipping is one of the more common complaints drivers have about the Honda Pilot’s newer models – model years 2019, 2018 and 2016. Honda has provided no solutions for this problem.

Total Transmission Failures

Perhaps one of the worst things to see in a vehicle is a history of transmission failures. These can occur for any of the other listed complaints and concerns. In short, drivers cannot keep operating the vehicle because the transmission is inoperable or significantly damaged. Replacing a transmission is expensive.

Some drivers report having routine service completed on the vehicle and not having any concerns with it until it failed at around 25,000 miles. Some noted a transmission light coming on the dash to warn them of a problem. The vehicles stopped and failed to restart.

Transmissions should last much longer than this. Early transmission failure may be a sign of poor maintenance, but many owners claim this is not the case. In all situations, transmission failures in relatively new cars – especially the 2016 model year – were a concern for many consumers.

Lurching Forward in “Park”

One of the lesser known concerns with the Honda Pilot is the vehicle lurching forward. This can happen when a driver switches gears, however, it has also occurred, reportedly, when drivers are in the “Park” position. Putting the car from “Drive” into “Park” caused it to lurch forward in more than one instance. This problem was reported by a few owners.

Some owners reported that the vehicle will jump forward, and, while doing so, it makes a loud noise. This occurs at a lower speed, such as when the user is in a parking lot.

The lurching forward sound while accelerating is more common than being in the “Park” position. The dealership and technicians working on the vehicle were unable to replicate this problem.

Transmission Fluid Leaks

For those thinking about purchasing an older model, it is important to know about the significant concerns with the 2005 Honda Pilot transmission. One of the biggest complaints is a fluid leak. In these vehicles, the transmission and engine coolant may leak. This may be due to the fact that they are in the same core.

Some drivers reported the vehicle suddenly stopped operation. Others noted that there was a defect in the transmission itself that caused these problems.

Some drivers had to replace the radiator and flush the transmission more than one time to keep it operational. This was done, in some cases, every 5,000 to 10,000 miles, which is far more frequent than is expected.

This model year does not have any transmission recalls. There have been numerous consumer complaints about the vehicle, though, including 174 out of 649 complaints related to the powertrain itself. There have been some service bulletins listed for this vehicle’s transmission. Yet, even those are few.

Should You Buy a Honda Pilot Knowing About Transmission Problems?

The number of transmission problems with the Honda Pilot’s most recent vehicles are not as significant as other vehicles. There are a lot of great features about this vehicle lineup that are often too hard to ignore.

It is wise to check out more information about the vehicle if you plan to purchase a pre-owned Honda Pilot. To do this, check out the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration website. Input the VIN or the make, model and year of the vehicle.

This lists all applicable consumer complaints (reported to the agency) as well as recalls and service bulletins about the vehicle. It will include concerns about the transmission and powertrain.

Owner Reviews

accountCircle Stephen on January 15, 2022
Transmission failure
I have 2017 Honda Pilot touring model. Bought it used with around 9k miles back in 2018. With in a few months of owning it I started getting engine light on saying the 02 sensor was bad and occasionally make it where my Pilot would move. I could reset it and move on. Do to the repair cost I couldn't afford to get it fixed. Finally a recall came out in 2021.Took it in had it repaired at 69k miles on it. They replaced the bad injector and reprogram (software update) the PGM-FI and TCM. Few months after the transmission would act like it couldn't find the gear and would go into neutral tell the rpms came down. It would do this every once in awhile but not consistent. Put off taking it in do to distance to service center and needing the vehicle to get back and forth to work. Well on my way back from a road trip it decided to go completely out. Had to get it towed to the Honda Service center closes by. My Honda is out of warranty and I'm and they are saying it'snot related to the software update. Looks like I'll have to pay around 7k out of pocket. This is the worst vehicle I have ever owned and will never by another Honda product.ill be reaching out to Honda USA but I'mnot very optimistic about it.
accountCircle Lorraine Mitchell on June 18, 2023
Transmission and paint issues
Bought new 2023 Honda Pilot Elite on 5/23/23. ONoticed a foot long horizontal paint run, a smaller paint run and a foot long vertical tape line. While in dispute on this on 6/11/23 I tried to back out of a parking space and the car kept shuddering to a stop. The car was shifting back into park. After several attempts to back up I finally was far enough out of the space so I put it in drive and hit the accelerator. It continued to return to park and shudder. Thought we were going to have to call for a tow. Shut off the car and cranked it but that didn’t help. After a couple of more tries, it went back to working. Now very concerned about our safety. What if the car returns to park while we are at cruising speeds??? Dealer said if they can’t replicate the issue then they can’t fix the issue.
accountCircle Éric carignan on April 3, 2022
Honda pilot 2016 touring
Acheter le pilote usager en 2018 avec 76000km. Premier problème bouton poussoir de démarrage défectueux, suspension molle de la misère à le tenir dans le chemin, remplacer les 4 amortisseur 1500$ douille de table avant fini donc remplacer les 2 tables avant ainsi que les douilles de barre stabilisatrice. Moteur de chaufferette très bruyant remplacer 2 fois . Système Bluetooth fonctionne 1 fois sur 2 ainsi que la radio . Arbre d'entraînement central défectueux remplacer un 90000km. Système Anti collision fait juste bugger, perte d antigel, transmission glisse et cogne...bref un vrai citron! Service Honda Canada complètement déconnecté fini pour moi honda
accountCircle Lorraine Mitchell on June 16, 2023
Paint issues and transmission concerns
Bought a new 2023 Pilot on 5/23/23. On 6/11/23 noticed a foot long horizontal paint drip, another smaller drip and a paint tape mark3” or so long and about a foot long that was vertical. Then today while backing out of a parking spot the car shuddered and stopped. Looked down and it went to park. It did it several times. Finally backed out enough we put it in drive and it did it again . We had this happen 8 or 10 times before it finally stopped.(went into park and shuddered to a stop). What if it does it at 60 mph?! We don’t want a Honda car. Thought they were better than this. We were so wrong.
accountCircle Jamie on July 21, 2023
Trasnmission Judder
Bought a 2020 Honda Pilot last year. Noticed it starts jerking when I hit 30 to 45 MPH. Honda place said to get a transmission flush done to help with problem. Now a year later it's getting worse. Took it back to dealer, they now say it needs another flush with software update, costing $550. 1st flush was at 42,000 miles, now I'm at 52,000. Service department says they have a TSB on it but not for my VIN. It will be a maintenance issue instead of a repair issue. So frustrated!
accountCircle Donna duffy on February 19, 2022
Ms
I had a 2005 Honda Pilot exl with all service done at recommended intervals. Never missed anything. The car had 201000 miles. It had absolutely no mechanical issues but I noticed rough shifting and slow, pulling acceleration. Eventuallythe transmission finally needed replacement and at $5500 it was not worth it for me. It was such a great car with no problems. But I wouldn’t recommend it or the 2012 I am now driving.
accountCircle Michelle on March 10, 2022
Transmission issues
I’ve had two Honda Pilots. 2016 and 2019. I traded the 16 for the 19 because Of the transmission slipping. I knew not to get another one but I really thought it was just the one vehicle bad since I’d owned three Hondas prior without any issues. Now I’m sitting here with a 2019 that is worse than the 2016 and Grainer Honda service department is a nightmare.
accountCircle Karen stout on August 16, 2023
Bad transmissions
2018 Honda pilot Need new transmission at 100,000. Miles did a trans Flush at 113,000 miles needs a new trans Honda knows they have a problem and will not help with the 10,000. Cost of a new transmission. They have had Transmission problems for years on the pilots. Stay clear
accountCircle Jon Peloso on January 15, 2023
Car in park portion
I have a 2021 Honda pilot with less than 20,000 miles and when I put it in park When I put my car in park position it made a loud noise and then went forward and scratch the front of my car . It happen 2 times is a half hour .I’m going Tuesday to see Honda
accountCircle Tom H. on May 19, 2023
Transmission
Ours is a 2019 and is developing significant transmission problems. The Honda dealer try’s to gloss it over saying just flush the fluid, but we have our doubts because things recently took a turn for the worse, with severe bucking and the like.
accountCircle Mark on October 30, 2021
2016 pilot transmission
The transmission flutters 2/300 rpm difference. They say no recall but extended a problem ticket to 80,000 car had 84000 so out of their warranty extension..400 to flush transmission to fix problem... Honda sucks
accountCircle Steve Drawhorn on September 13, 2022
2021 Honda Pilot
I have a 2021 Honda Pilot with 15,000 miles and one year old. Transmission had to be replace. I think it starting to start same problem again. It wouldn’t come out of park ? Same thing happen before.
accountCircle Jon p on January 23, 2023
2021 Honda pilot
The car start moving foward from the park postion sometimes . Brought to dealer for 4 days and couldn’t find problem than took it home next day and it happened again , not sure what to do
accountCircle walter merritt on November 4, 2022
What is the problem
My wife parked her honda pilot and was washing it off and it started moveing forward and almost ran over her what is the problem
avatar Sandy B
Sandy B. has written for The New York Times, Cleveland Magazine, and many online publications. She long-ago ditched the minivan life for the off-roading Ford Explorer (and hoping to restore a Shelby Mustang!)
  • Articles
  • chevronRightAlternative
  • Honda Pilot Transmission Problems Worth Knowing Of