2018 Jeep Compass Problems Include Excessive Oil Consumption That May Lead to Engine Stall and Electrical System Failure

Andrew Ganz
Apr 19, 2022

The 2018 Jeep Compass is a small SUV with rugged looks that comes with some problems. This entry to the Jeep brand has been recalled six times and has a subpar reliability record, though crash-test results have been fairly good.

2018 Jeep Compass - Photo by Stellantis

Key Points

  • The 2018 Jeep Compass has six recalls, and five of them are for dangerous problems that could lead to engine failure or loss of vehicle control.
  • Just as concerning are the nearly 550 owner complaints, which often center around excessive oil consumption that can lead to the engine stalling.
  • Complaints lodged with the NHTSA also mention electrical issues that could lead to the engine failing to start.
  • Reportedly, the stop/start system can occasionally fail to restart until the transmission in put in park.
  • While not the lowest in its class, the 2018 Jeep Compass does have fewer recalls and registered complaints than many rivals.

2018 Jeep Compass - Photo by Stellantis

2018 Jeep Compass Was Recalled Six Times, Including Over Reduced Braking Performance and Loose Airbag Hardware That Can Become a Projectile Upon Deployment

A total of six recalls have been issued for the 2018 Jeep Compass, and most of them are for particularly dangerous potential problems that could lead to engine stall or loss of vehicle control. The least serious recall is over an issue with the instrument cluster display being too bright.

The most concerning safety recall covers passenger-side airbags that may have loose metal mounting hardware that could become a projectile during airbag deployment.

Certain 2018 Compass SUVs may have rear brake caliper pistons with insufficient coating that causes gas pockets to form, potentially reducing braking performance.

Additionally, Jeep alerted owners of 2018 Compass models that may have a major component of the front suspension incorrectly welded, which could lead to loss of vehicle control.

Another serious recall affects certain 2018 Jeep Compass vehicles with the 2.4L engine, which may have a cracked oil pump that can result in failure. If the oil pump fails, the engine will stall, increasing the risk of a crash.

2018 Jeep Compass - Photo by Stellantis

2018 Compass Owners Complain About Engine Stall, Heavy Oil Consumption, and Finicky Start/Stop System That May Fail to Restart

Owners of the 2018 Jeep Compass have registered nearly 550 complaints with the NHTSA. That’s a lot more than rivals like the Subaru Crosstrek (137 complaints) and Honda HR-V (42 complaints).

The vast majority of complaints center around the engine and powertrain, including issues with excessive oil consumption that can lead to engine stall.

Even drivers who say they change the oil regularly note that the SUV can still run low on oil with little warning.

“Excessive oil consumption lead to multiple incidents of stalling while driving,” says one 2018 Jeep Compass owner. “Vehicle had trouble restarting in the middle of the road. Almost got hit several times by other motorists.”

Owner complaints also note that the stop/start system, which is designed to turn the engine off at idle to save on fuel, can occasionally fail to restart the vehicle. The driver must manually put the transmission in “park” and re-cycle the ignition switch to restart the Jeep.

2018 Jeep Compass - Photo by Stellantis

Real Owners in Jeep Enthusiast Forums and on Vehicle History Sound Off About Malfunctioning Headlights, Slow Pick Up, and Vehicles Failing to Shut Off

Many 2018 Jeep Compass owners are sounding off in fan forums, addressing previously mentioned common problems with engine stalls and heavy oil consumption. One owner in a thread on My Jeep Compass includes a unique issue with his vehicle’s circuitry.

“The headlights, taillights, and interior lights began to sort of pulsate–randomly dimming and brightening,” he says. “It is not a fast pulsation, very slow, but absolutely noticeable.”

Another My Jeep Compass user mentioned having a problem where their 2018 Jeep Compass Limited would not turn off. “It would not turn off even though we tried several times pressing the start/stop button,” says the owner. “After about a half-hour. the car shut off on its own.”

In Vehicle History‘s owner reviews, the 2018 Jeep Compass is rated at 4.4 out of five stars. But there are many complaints from owners that echo the problems with random stalling, excessive oil consumption, and electrical glitches.

“It is a small SUV with a slow pick up when mashing on the gas,” says one owner. “Plus, it had electrical problems and the tire pressure light always comes on.”

Another owner adds, “The electronics have started to get all funky after two years, like the backup camera sometimes doesn’t function properly.”

2018 Jeep Compass - Photo by Stellantis

2018 Compass Has a Mixed Safety Record, Scoring Average with the NHTSA, but Landing a Top Safety Pick with the IIHS

The Insurance Institue for Highway Safety gives the 2018 Compass high marks, labeling it a Top Safety Pick thanks to “Good” ratings in most of its tests.

However, many 2018 Jeep Compass owners who are sounding off in NHTSA complaints and in Jeep enthusiast forums mention common problems with engine stalls, excessive oil consumption, and random issues like the vehicle failing to shut off.

The model year’s six recalls also mostly cover dangerous potential problems with engines stalling and loss of vehicle control. So, this is one Jeep that should be carefully considered before deciding to add it to your driveway.

Photos: Stellantis

Frequently Asked Questions

By Stephanie Stephan | Apr 19, 2022

Is the 2018 Jeep Compass Reliable?

The 2018 Jeep Compass received a very low-reliability rating of 2.5 out of five from J.D. Power. 541 NHTSA complaints exist for stalling, hard shifting, and electrical problems. The 2018 Jeep Compass’ start/stop function is also known to fail.

Does the 2018 Jeep Compass Have Transmission Problems?

The oil feed tubes attached to the transmission valve body are damaged in some 2018 Jeep Compasses and shifting out of fourth gear may become impossible. 101 NHTSA complaints exist for the 2018 Jeep Compass’ powertrain. Engine shutoff, stalling, and loss of acceleration power are commonly reported.
accountCircle Rob S
You have the option to see how many mpg per trip.
I have had no problems with my Acura ILX. It drives smooth and is fuel efficient. It's also fun to drive and the pick up is quick and the take off is quick. It was a great choice to buy. I would recommend it to anyone who is looking to buy a midsize or small car for comfortable ride and sleek and modern look.
accountCircle Greyson I
Great car and good mpg would recommend.
The car works great gets me to and from where I need to be. Drives smooth and has some good acceleration. The miles per gallon is pretty good and the tank is like 11 gallons which will take me around 350 miles usually. Also, the interior is very comfortable, I really like the leather.
accountCircle Samuel W
The gas mileage is the best thing about this car.
My vehicle is very nice and rides very smoothly. I am not sure if it's me running things over or if it's just the tires but I have a lot of problems with the tire pressure. Other than that, I cannot complain about the gas mileage or anything else. Overall a great vehicle.
accountCircle Bonnie A
Great gas mileage and performs well when taken care of with regular maintenance.
I like that it is fuel efficient, reliable, and never has given me any problems. I wish it took regular gasoline and not premium though.
accountCircle Dynel M
It had good fuel economy.
Love the size, gas mileage, interior, color, and the smooth ride. I dislike that it is not as fast as my Acura to that has a v6 engine.
accountCircle Sandy M
My Acura is a small luxury vehicle that gets great gas mileage.
This car is the perfect size for me. It gets great gas mileage. It is black and so pretty when it is clean.
accountCircle Dawn H
My car saves me lots of money on gasoline. It gets really good gas mileage.
I would like it to be much bigger than what it is.
accountCircle Bill B
Acura ilx: The 2016 acura ilx has nimble handling, a comfortable ride.
The 2016 acura ilx has nimble handling, a comfortable ride, and great gas mileage estimates, but it finishes in the bottom half of our luxury small car rankings because of its meager performance chops and uninspired interior. Pros & cons. Nimble handling. Great fuel economy. Spacious interior for the class. Limited passing power. Cheaper interior for a luxury sedan. Seats lack side support. Awkward available dual-screen system. New for 2016. Updated powertrain. Updated exterior styling.

Owner Reviews

accountCircle Terri Copher on September 7, 2022
Worse new vehicle I ever bought!
I have experienced every single problem mentioned in these reviews except for rust. But then I have not looked underneath the car. I have had this vehicle towed to side of road with heavy traffic twice to get out of danger (after dying with no warning) to put oil in to get started up again. Has died MANY times with out towing. I carry a case of oil with me always. Oil consumption evaluation done at the dealship one of the many times having it in there,nothing done because it wasjust inside the lower range for ok. Back up camera out more than working. Recalls addressed, have replaced brakes twice, main and aux batteries and radio. I have dealt with two jeep dealerships over these issues. Service guy at one laughs and says "you should take a big hammer to it" guy at other dealership says "I have worked on these for years and there is reason why I drive a Ford". This Compass is a total piece of c**p and dealer knows it and does not care that purchasers have to deal with all the problems. I traded a Dodge Journey that had lots of issues for this Compass that is worse. I will never buy from Dodge/Jeep again. I tell everyone that will listen! I am a single senior citizen who has been misled and taken advantage of!!!
accountCircle Brittany on August 10, 2022
Nice car but...
I have a 2018 Jeep Compass Sport (Manual). I enjoy the drive of this car, however, the oil consumption is insane! I thought it wasme being careless and not changing the oil enough but come to find out, it was the car. I took my jeep to the dealership for an oil change and the next service was supposed to be at 83,678 miles (estimate mileage). I was driving down the road and the low oil message FLASHED, really quickly across the message screen but I kept and just made a mental note that I was soon due for a oil change. No more than 3 days later the message flashed again and the car started driving as if it didn't want to drive. Later on that same day I was driving down the road and the car shut off. I checked the oil and the stick was dry. At that time I was at 83,630 miles. Only about 50 miles until I needed a oil change and there was NO oil to change. I do see that this is an on going issue with Jeep Compasses and I am hoping that there will be a fix for this soon or I may just have to get rid of it, which I don't want to do. I drive on the highway everyday for work and I can't be running out of oil and the car shutting of like that.
accountCircle F.L.G on July 20, 2022
No fix for all issues
Not only did I learn that excessive oil consumption causes the transmission warning but the electrical system is trash. The infotainment cuts off and on, only 1 USB port works, the alternative battery died (replaced by dealer for 300 +dollar charge. Lifetime warranty only recognized at that specific dealer), torque, transmission, start stop, silent hill??, brakes on and on lights flash. Car shuts down. Dealer says I needed new battery for 500 dollars to remove check engine light. I purchased battery somewhere else. Dealer replaced alternative battery. Lights still flash. Car shut off on my 17 yr old!!! By the waythe car was purchased last year. Has 43000 miles on it.
accountCircle Kandice on November 28, 2023
DO NOT PURCHASE A 2018 JEEP COMPASS
The vehicle is a death trap. Will leave you stranded in the middle of a road or highway with no warning at all due to burning oil. I had 2,500 miles before my next oil change and had to have the vehicle towed to a Tires Plus where they advised the car had no oil. No warning light was ever prompted and I had 2,500 miles before the next oil change. A number of recalls have been reported and yet I have not recieved once notice from the Jeep dealership. The Jeep dealership is aware of this issue and do not advise potential customers of the issue. DO NOT BUY A JEEP COMPASS 2018 unless you're into putting your life and the life of others at danger/death.
accountCircle Jessica Lowman on March 2, 2022
Burns Oil
I discovered that the Compass has a serious problem burning oil when it just shut off on me while driving. I was thankful I hadn’t pulled out into traffic. When I got it to come back on, the low oil light came on. My dad came and checked it and there was no oil in it! I was 2,000 miles away from being due for an oil change. My dad filled it up with oil and then took it to the dealer. They said they would look at it again when it was time for an oil change.
accountCircle David C on February 20, 2022
Fun little Jeep, but there's better out there.
It has a start and stop system that only seems to waste gas turning the engine off and on when you start and stop, once the car hits the inside temperature you want. So every time I get in the vehicle I have to turn that function off with a button by the shifter. There's no setting in the car to disable it and that's really annoying. My other main issue is that for a 4 cylinder it is terrible on gas, my 6 cylinder charger got better mpgs.
accountCircle K on October 21, 2021
Problem vehicle
I have a 2018 Compass Trailhawk. I bought it with 4k and now have 40k. I hate this vehicle. I have had nothing but problems. Brakes, electrical system and now the AC went out. Needed four new tires, too. It has NO pick up at all and is sluggish at times. I never take a chance on crossing over lanes of road. I'd never make it and get hit if a car is too close! Cannot wait to get rid of it!
accountCircle Angela H on January 31, 2022
Jeep compass issues to include oil burning and vehicle turning off.
The engine oil burns causing more oil changes than normal and my vehicle shut off on me while I was driving down a major road. One time I had my oil replaced. I was told to bring it back for my next oil change 8000 miles later. At the 4000 mile mark, I was driving down the road and my car turned off on me. Come to find out, there was absolutely no oil in my car!
accountCircle Robin S on December 30, 2021
Acceleration Issue
The reason that I give it at 2/5 is because the engine is extremely lethargic and it takes quite a while to get up to a decent speed. It also has an automatic shut-off button to save gas. For example, when you stop at a light, the vehicle will shut off; then when you take your foot off the break it will start again.
accountCircle Debbie on October 28, 2023
Jeep Compass
I had owned a 2000 Jeep Cherokee for many years. Hardly had any issue. I went to a newer Cherokee, go in a crash. Went and bought a 2018 Compass. We’re I find oil consumption sucks. I check oil bi weekly and the coolant. Same issue. Check that weekly. My question is is there a solution or a repair for this yet??
accountCircle Tabitha A on April 3, 2022
I wish it would go faster.
I have always wanted a jeep, but this was a disappointment! It makes me miss my old ford focus! I do not like the feature where the car shuts off at stop lights, but I do like that I can shut that feature off. There is a lot of room in the back at least and that is nice, but I will not be renewing my lease.
accountCircle Theresa M on October 17, 2021
Jeep compass 2018 = stress.
Constantly in the shop. Check engine light, battery light and auto on/off light constantly going off. Been in the shop 4 times in 2.5 months. Then three days later the exact issue comes right back. Getting very old and very discouraging that I still have 6 years left on this vehicle.
accountCircle Maia M on October 13, 2021
Will never buy a jeep compass again.
The interior lights on the panel and drive shifter do not work. The backup camera will stop working while using. The engine makes a very loud sound. I have had to have several components replaced on the car like the wiper fluid container because the parts are off. It is only 2018.
accountCircle Gabrielle B on February 5, 2022
2018 jeep compass review
Have had issues since about a month after I got it. Automatic start has issues. Transmission shifts funny will drive normal and when pushing on gas rpm goes up and it jerks. It has no pick up at all. Also has stalled out quite a few times and low oil pressure light pops up a lot.
accountCircle Michelle Z on July 12, 2021
Lemon not a gem. Thought I purchased a beautiful reliable vehicle.
Suspension is terrible, and makes for an enjoyable ride. Electrical problems. Transmission makes a rumbling noise at speeds over 30 mph. Slow pick up. Goes through oil much faster than it is supposed to. Jeep has some of these issues on recalls and some they just never resolve.
accountCircle Maria A on February 22, 2022
Not reliable after year 2.
The main problem we've been having with the car after only three years is the coil packs have gone out and the automated engine has had to be maintained and replaced. That is a lot of engine issue for a car that hasn't been used for heavy duty travel and just regular commutes.
accountCircle Davona E on April 15, 2022
Runner car is what I call it.
Lots of rusting most likely from sitting too long. The frame rusted and my tire rod broke. The car also has to be taken to a dealership just to have simple things done like a transmission check. Also I experience several electrical issues as well.
accountCircle Tami Salens on June 30, 2021
Poor quality
In 2 years, I had to replace all 4 tires because they were mid grade tires. I had to replace their sway bars, pay for 2 computer upgrades & fix the read wiper mechanism. Nothing was covered under warranty. New car-25 months old
accountCircle Jeff Snyder on February 15, 2022
Too Many Issues
Burns oil Shifts terrible. Dealership does nothing for problems. Dealership suggested I carry oil with me. Already been towed in once for low oil
accountCircle Alisha C on March 29, 2022
Has remote start and can be located from anywhere
Has been in the shop 8 times. Has had many issues.
  • Articles
  • chevronRightAlternative
  • 2018 Jeep Compass Problems Include Excessive Oil Consumption That May Lead to Engine Stall and Electrical System Failure