Crash Test Rating
Source   NHTSA
MPG (up to)
17 -20 City / 24 -26 HWY
Horsepower
175 -250
Seats
5
Front angle medium view.

Positive Owner Reviews

accountCircle Vicki B
A very dependable car with great styling.
I love it because it is dependable. Comfortable. Great in the snow and rain. It fits me well. Not too big or too small.
accountCircle Paul G
Good economy with this car.
My car is a good value. It gets good mileage. It handles well in all weather including the snow and ice of winter. My only complaint is that every time we have snow the doors all freeze shut. . Even though I am retired I only buy gas once a month. In the market.
accountCircle Ashley F
Best vehicle ever! Buy a Subaru.
My Subaru is a get up and go car. Decent gas mileage. I have had it for 4 years and have had no problems until recently the coolant was leaking into the head gaskets. Apparently that is a common problem with Subarus. They will run forever. I hope to keep mine as long as I can.
accountCircle Heidi H
Awesome awd,fun to drive,good gas mileage
It has a fer problems, i love my car, it drives great, has ac,
accountCircle Salina B
I love my 2009 Subaru legacy 25i special edition sedan!
The 2009 Subaru legacy 25i limited edition sedan is the best car I've ever driven hands down! The all wheel drive makes the mountain and windy roads where I live a breeze to drive down not to mention the gas mileage is really good. There is no Bluetooth compatibility but compared to the other features its no problem!
accountCircle Nancy S
140000 miles and still running like brand new
Car is all wheel drive therefore is extremely reliable in rain and snow. Great gas mileage especially on the highway. Very comfortable ride and handles well. Sporty yet good enough to be a family car. Over 140000 miles and still running like a champ
accountCircle Robert H
The fact that I'm spite of being a European vehicle, maintenance availability has always been there for me.
I have a 2008 Legacy -not 2009- very impressed with the make - will definitely by another Same make -Excellent Auto !
accountCircle Barbara R
Subarus are great cars, last a long time, low maintenance, fun to drive.
We love our Subaru. It handles great in snow and ice, very comfortable to drive, the all wheel drive gives us security. All around great car!!

Negative Owner Reviews

accountCircle Aaron Balsley
My daughters life
I own a 2009 subaru legacy and my 16yr old daughter and I were recently in an accident.She was sitting in the backseat when we were hit head on. The seatbelt tore her bowel from her abdominal wall and severed her bowel in two places. She had serious internal bleeding,has had multiple blood transfusions and surgeries and is on a breathing machine still sidated in the icu.Has this sort of thing happened to anyone else?
accountCircle Tyler N
Subaru Legacy and its problems.
The vehicle starts to breakdown around 100,000 miles. The interior of the vehicle ends up falling apart the most. You have to worry about the window trim coming apart, trunk interior carpentry falls off, cup holders come out. As the outside goes, headlights and tail lights constantly burn out.
accountCircle Eric M
Good on gas low maintenance good sports car and hope family car.
Low profile tire causes a lot of flats during potholes, airbag problem.Recall. Other than that it is good on gas accelerate fast nice easy car good on gas low maintenance cheap to maintain easy to take care of nice looking model. Good as sports car or family car good on miles.
accountCircle Ted L
It's so dependable the four wheel drive will never let you down
It's good if you live in the city. All around good car. Fast when it needs to be also for those who like to have fun on the open road. It's grey and does what most car can. Has ton of electronically functioned that I'm sure many of us love to utilize on the day to day basis
accountCircle Karim O
The Subaru Legacy is just an OK vehicle; at least my model which is the 2009. It will get you from point A to point B but it is not particularly flashy or comfortable. The interior is made out of cheap plastics and materials. The engine is not powerful and it does seem to always have some sort of light on even though it doesn't have that many miles. It does have 4 Wheel Drive which is a plus.
Subaru Legacy: It will get you from point A to point B but you will not be exhilarated by the journey. It is just an average car all the way around except it does have four wheel drive.
accountCircle Steven D
The car is average everyday driving car.
The performance is fine. The vehicle is 10 years old and is a base model. The car gets 25 miles per gallon on the highway. It does have all power features and a sunroof. The car does handle very well in the snow being an AWD vehicle. I feel that the tires wear unevenly which could be an issue.
accountCircle Amanda K
Make sure you get the right tires!! The wrong tires messed it up.
It was my husband's car that I 'adopted' after marriage. It works like a charm for him, but it's a total lemon for me. I've always had Fords and Chevys, and would not get another Subaru.

Subaru Legacy Models

Models also known as Trim Levels, are used to identify a vehicle's level of equipment or special features.

car
Base
175 HP 22 MPG 5 Seats
car
Special Edition
175 HP 22 MPG 5 Seats
car
Ltd
175 HP 22 MPG 5 Seats
car
3.0R
245 HP 20 MPG 5 Seats
car
3.0R Ltd
245 HP 20 MPG 5 Seats
car
GT Ltd
250 HP 20 MPG 5 Seats
car
3.0R Ltd w/Nav
245 HP 20 MPG 5 Seats
car
GT Ltd w/Nav
250 HP 20 MPG 5 Seats
car
GT Spec B w/Nav
243 HP 20 MPG 5 Seats
Photos may not match model

2009 Subaru Legacy Owner Reviews

4.23
61 Reviews
close Write Review
5 stars 39%
4 stars 49%
3 stars 8%
2 stars 2%
1 star 2%
accountCircle Ted L on March 26, 2021
It's so dependable the four wheel drive will never let you down
It's good if you live in the city. All around good car. Fast when it needs to be also for those who like to have fun on the open road. It's grey and does what most car can. Has ton of electronically functioned that I'm sure many of us love to utilize on the day to day basis
accountCircle Tiffani B on March 13, 2021
It has been the most reliable vehicle I have owned.
My legacy is smooth riding. I love the large trunk space. I have had it for almost 7 years and haven't had any major issues with it. It's a 2008 but that option wasn't in your yearea list.

Pros from Owners

likeFilled Sara V.

It has all-wheel drive which is great for snowy and icy road conditions. It also warms up pretty quickly and has heated seats. It speeds up pretty quickly so merging onto busy highways is easy. Overall, it is great to drive.

likeFilled Robert S.

It has low mileage and has been serviced regularly. It gets me where I need to go and I have never had it break down on me. It is comfortable to drive and does particularly well on the mountains and in winter weather.

likeFilled Kristen T.

It is small but not too small, also there are four doors instead of two which allows me to fit more people in the car. It also runs well despite the fact that it is an older car. There were not many times where I had to bring the car to a repair shop due to technical difficulties.

likeFilled Nicole P.

The pros of the legacy are it has a comfortable interior, adjustable seats, hands free control on the steering wheel for radio/etc.. It also has a sunroof which is wonderful to use in the summer. It has great gas mileage and I do not have to fill up often.

Cons from Owners

dislikeFilled Sara V.

The engine of any Subaru is hard to work on. Servicing tends to be really expensive and time-consuming. I would not recommend buying this car used for that reason. I have had a few minor issues with the engine, but it is so time-consuming that the labor costs are outrageous.

dislikeFilled Robert S.

It is equipped with a tire pressure monitor that always shows low pressure. It is fine for everyday storage, but I prefer something that I can haul large items home from the store occasionally. It has a cracked windscreen.

dislikeFilled Kristen T.

It does not look as nice as I would like it to but that is due to the fact that it is a 2009. Also, I do not like the fact that the sunroof automatically rolls back when you press the button once, I would prefer it to only go as long as you are holding the button.

dislikeFilled Nicole P.

The cons of the vehicle are, it has consistent issues with tire pressure monitor, which have had to be replaced a few times. It also needs regular wash/maintenance because Subarus have a tendency towards rusting on the bottom.

Ranks #7 Midsize Cars by Owners

The 2009 Subaru Legacy has an average owner rating of 4.23 out of 5 which ranks it #7 of 12 other Midsize Cars.

1
car
4.48
2
car
4.43
7
car
4.23

Ranks #9 Midsize Cars by Fuel Economy

The 2009 Subaru Legacy has a combined MPG of 28 which ranks it #9 of 12 other Midsize Cars.

1
car
35 MPG
2
car
34 MPG
9
car
26 MPG

Is The 2009 Subaru Legacy A Good Car?

Yes I very much like my Subaru legacy special edition vehicle that is from the year 2009. It is a reliable car that is easy to keep up with maintenance and repairs.
Peter L.
It is an excellent vehicle. I have had mine for nearly 11 years and have had no major issues with it. I recommend it to anyone looking for a reliable used car.
Frank R.
Yes it is reliable and runs in all types of weather. I service it regularly and have had no problems.
AMBER J.
Yes very reliable and fun to drive. It has great electronic features and a sunroof! The gas mileage is nice as well. This vehicle is great in snow and winters conditions because of the all wheel... Read More
Jessica J.
Yes, it is. I enjoy driving it on a daily basis. I have no had any major issues, or problems since I purchased the vehicle.
Charles R.
So far the car has worked well, for me even with the high mileage, it is a stick shift even though I would prefer and automatic
Anthony E.
I love my Subaru!! It's the best car I have ever bought. I will never own anything other than a Subaru, if and when the day comes I can no longer drive my Subaru..I'll get a new Subaru
Patty Y.

How Reliable Is The 2009 Subaru Legacy?

The 2009 Subaru legacy special edition is a reliable car. I have had some regular repair and maintenance issues that I needed to keep up with but that is expected.
Peter L.
This car is very reliable. As long as the driver performs the necessary maintenance at the recommended intervals, the car should run fine.
Frank R.
No it runs any time I need it and has enough power to pull over the mountains. It always gets me to and from my destination.
Audrey A.
Very reliable vehicle with minimal issues. I am starting to see minor control issues. The driving window is glitchy and the dashboard control center sometimes does work properly but other than that... Read More
Jacob V.
It has been a very reliable vehicle. Have not had any problems with the vehicle as of today. I do change the oil on a regular basis.
Melanie W.
It has high mileage, and I wish it was a automatic but so far not problems and it has been very reliable
Karen W.
It's completely reliable. I have only good things to say about my Subaru and can't see myself owning Anything else.
Tamara A.

Is The 2009 Subaru Legacy A Good Value?

I bought my car from a used dealership and the previous owner was leasing the car so I think we got a good deal.
Peter L.
I bought my car for $23,500. I paid it off in 2009 and it has helped me recoup its value many times over.
Frank R.
It doesn't cost much to run and I only have to do basic maintenance I take good care of it and that helps keep costs down.
Wendy W.
I believe I paid around 15,000. All Subaru vehicles are on the pricey side, but the money you spend is an investment in your safety. Well worth the money in my book.
Harley R.
I bought it at a used car dealership and it was a very good value for the car except the high Mileage
Beatrice C.
I bought it used a few years ago and paid six thousand for it...it's an incredible car and excellent value.
Katie B.

Related Articles for 2009 Subaru Legacy

From the Vehicle History blog

car
2008 Subaru Legacy Review: A Sporty, Comfortable Sedan That’s Priced to Move, but Only at the Entry Level
car
2017 Subaru Legacy Review: Reliable Midsize Sedan With Reasonable Ownership Costs

Frequently Asked Questions

What's the 2009 Subaru Legacy transmission fluid type?

Answer: The 2009 Subaru Legacy came factory standard with A4-speed automatic transmission but the higher level trims are going to come equipped with A5-speed automatic transmission. Both models are going to need to run...

How much oil does the 2009 Subaru Legacy take?

Answer: The amount Your 2009 Subaru Legacy can take in oil depends on the size of the engine. The 2.5L engine can take up to 4.2 US quarts of engine oil with a filter. The 3.0L engine can take up to 5.8 US quarts of...

Does the 2009 Subaru Legacy have a timing belt or chain?

Answer: The 2009 Subaru Legacy comes with a timing belt that the manufacturer recommends replacing every 105,000 miles. If You don't do this then it can still be damaged and in some cases fail. If this happens You will...

Answers are provided by third parties. We do not guarantee accuracy of responses

Safety & Reliability

NHTSA Logo
NHTSA Crash Test

Overall

Front

Rollover

Side

*National Highway Traffic Safety Administration
IIHS Logo
IIHS Crash Test

Moderate Overlap Front

Side

Roof Strength

Not Rated

Driver-side Overlap Front

Not Rated
*Insurance Institute for Highway Safety