Used 2019 Subaru Forester Buyer’s Guide

Tyler Linn
Aug 27, 2021

The 2019 Subaru Forester is great off-road, offers comfy cargo space, and is one of the safest vehicles around. Sadly, reliability issues and an underpowered engine keep it from fully stealing our hearts.

VehicleHistory Image

likeFilled The Good
The 2019 Subaru Forester is easily a top-five pick when considering utility, visibility, and safety. Its AWD system and X-Mode also offer the versatility any trail hunter needs to thrive.
dislikeFilled The Bad
The 2019 Forester could stand to add more power for things like passing or merging onto an interstate. The laundry list of issues like chipping windshields and malfunctioning liftgates is also a cause for concern.
checkCircleAlternativeBold The Bottom Line
A safe, capable SUV both on and off-road, the 2019 Forester is a good vehicle to consider. However, it struggles with reliability issues, lack of power, and general blandness.

Positive Owner Reviews

accountCircle Joan L
Highly efficient and cost effective.
The suv that we own is a subaru forester limited. It is very safe, easy to use and highly fuel efficient especially on long interstate drives. It is also spacious and is able to sit us comfortably even with a car seat in place. It also is big enough to carry furniture around.
accountCircle Hannah B
My Subaru forester review.
The Subaru forester is absolutely amazing. It is safe and super easy to drive. I love all the safety features from back up camera, keeping you in your lane, to pre breaking collision as well as the great sound system, heated seats, open lift gate and huge sunroof.
accountCircle Lori M
The reliable big red adventure.
I love Subaru vehicles, they are reliable, attractive and come with a variety of options. They are comfortable to drive and depending on the make and model have really good pick up. I have had problems with connectivity (phone to car) at times, but it has not been a big deal.
accountCircle Shradha S
Great car but fix the back seat angle.
The Subaru forester is a great car for families and inexperienced drivers as it aids in safety and is relatively simple to function. The seats are comfortable and soft, the mobility of the driver seat is wonderful for most heights and lengths. However the back seats of the car are not as set forward, it is at a backwards leaning angle and it can be quite annoying to sit on as a passenger.
accountCircle Gail J J
I said everything on previous screen.
Very comfortable to drive with good visibility. Many safety features, warning lights and sounds. Still have to look everything up in manual to figure out how to make changes and even with manual some changes are difficult. Gas mileage is good. Love the backup camera. Controls are very accessible even if I do not always know what to do with them.
accountCircle Ashley R
I love my forester, and I would recommend it.
Great ride, smooth, great turn radius, visibility, height, space in cabin, and engine performance. Very durable car, very easy to maneuver. Great for people of all sizes. Great gas mileage for the size, I get almost 27 miles per gallon. 10/10 would recommend.
accountCircle Savanna L
Sub forester 2019 sport edition.
Perfect vehicle for any outdoor adventure! Wanna go camping? Plenty of room is included, heated seats, sunroof with a perfect view, sports edition was my choice (can you blame me). If you're looking for the perfect sporty vehicle, you've found it! Ice silver was my color choice.
accountCircle Brooke L
I have always wanted a moon roof it is just a perk to an already great car.
My forester is almost a year old and I still love everything about it. I have owned 2 subaru’s in my life and will only ever own a Subaru. It is reliable and safe for our growing family. It rides smooth and is comfortable for longer trips. Also does well on gas for a crossover.

Negative Owner Reviews

accountCircle Thomas
Camera Broke Already
I have had the 2019 forester sport not even 3 months and brought into the shop for Eye Sight Indicator issue. They tell me they have to order a new camera not happy.
accountCircle Lincoln Millstein
Dangerous car
This was the third Subaru I owned. It has a bad design flaw which is dangerous. The right rear roof support looks just like the front grill of an oncoming car. So many times I’ve attempted a lane change but pulled back. Subaru customer service had no solutions.. Buy an Outback if you must have a Subaru. The entertainment package is also a disaster but that’s another story...
accountCircle MG
Navigation System SUCKS!!!
Won't let you enter addresses like a normal NAV system. Must enter everything in a search box and the searches are usually unsuccessful even for common points of interest and street names. Voice recognition is awful and completely useless. Paid 1500 for top of the line NAV system and ot is complete GARBAGE!
accountCircle Peter Warburton Shih
2019 Forester is a Disappointment!
I’ve been driving the Forester Touring model for 6 months and just went to my Connecticut dealer for the 6000 mile service just last week. Let me first say that the dealer is terrific. The tailgate has been a continuing problem as it doesn’t always open and now opens less than one foot and must be then manually pushed up. I’m told that you must hold the open button for 8+ seconds to force it to open. Dealer ordered a part which hopefully will be fixed by next week. Meanwhile, the hazard light is also not working. Although the engine was reported to be delivering more horsepower, it is noisy and labors until it reaches about 30mph. The 2019 Honda CRV is quieter and peppier. Steering was extraordinarily squirrelly and I asked the service manager to check it out. Apparently the “Vehicle Dynamics Control” system was in “on mode” and interfered with my steering. This feature as well as “Eyesight” is something I could and prefer to do without. What I could use are garage openers as standard equipment. I’m told that I can install a special mirror with garage opener buttons at a cost of several hundred dollars. My previous car was a Toyota Forerunner Limited with factory garage opener buttons that I bought new in 2003 and ran it for over 250,000 miles. I now seriously regret not going with Toyota or Honda.
accountCircle Lon6
Seats are horrible..
Love the Forester, ride,handling and economy will allways impress me, and, thiers impressive power for hills.highway.. The down side, seats are terrible for long drivesi in Touring model. Drove from Calgary AB to Crescent city California...and back.. Seats are garbage....on long drives..
accountCircle Jim W
Radio problems
I have almost 11,000 miles on my new Forrester. Very frustrated with radio issues, specifically that it continually loses the station presets. Appears there are many complaints about this and has been an issue for a long time.
accountCircle Brenda M
Subaru forester needs to fix headlights.
Pros:starts easy, looks nice. Like doors locking automatically. Glove department is a decent size, as is the console. The backup guides on the camera are very helpful. The hooks inside the cargo area are helpful to hang groceries on and keep them in place. The automatic cargo door is helpful in opening and closing. Cons: the headlights are a nightmare. They do not project high enough to see road signs. They will not go to bright in totally dark situations.
accountCircle Aly K
Subaru forester review for families.
Does not ride as nicely as the outback. Louder road noise. The screen also is not as nice as my previous outback. The car is very reliable and has not had any issues to date. It is a good family car but could be small for older kids. Will trade it in when able.

A Brief Overview of the 2019 Subaru Forester

Subaru Forester - Photo by Subaru

  • 2019 Foresters are maintaining prices relatively close to their original MSRPs. Expect to pay between $22,000 and $30,000 for a used Forester at around 40,000 miles.
  • However, the 2.5-liter Boxer engine and Lineartronic CVT fail to produce a sufficient amount of power for even basic highway maneuvers.
  • Fuel economy falls short of the EPA rating of 29 mpg combined. Most owners report an average of 26 mpg.
  • Cargo space was a win for the 2019 Forester, netting it a “Best Car to Buy 2019” honor. The 2019 model increased cargo space to 76.1 cu. ft., which is a gain of 1.9 cu. ft.
  • All versions of the 2019 Forester came standard with safety features like driver assist technology, but the 2019 model year did still have three rather serious recalls.

2019 Subaru Forester Offers Four Trim Levels & Plenty of Extras

Subaru Forester - Photo by Subaru

The 2019 Subaru Forester is available in five distinct trim levels. Each one builds upon the previous and offers additional features. Ranging from your bare-bones Base model all the way up to the top-of-the-line Forester Touring, there’s sure to be a Forester that will fit your needs.

Forester Base is a Competitive Entry-level Trim with Many Standard Features

The least-equipped Forester trim simply goes by Forester. For the sake of clarity, we’ll call it Base. It is a great option for anyone who simply needs an A-to-B vehicle with tons of storage, decent safety features, and AWD. A few noteworthy standard items include a rear backup camera, LED headlights, and a 6.5-inch display.

Additional features include:

  • 17-inch steel wheels
  • Six-way adjustable driver’s seat
  • Automatic climate control system

Forester Premium Adds a Few Creature Comforts Like Available Panoramic Moonroof

If you’re looking for an average weekend warrior with a few creature comforts, the Forester Premium is your best bet. The Forester Premium offers a number of desirable upgrades to the previous trim, like 17-inch alloys and a leather-wrapped steering wheel, without adding too much in cost.

Adds to or replaces features offered on the Forester Base, plus:

  • Panoramic moonroof, roof rails, and rear spoiler
  • 10-way power-adjustable driver’s seat
  • Rear A/C vents and 4G LTE Wi-Fi capability
  • Single function X-mode with hill-descent control

Forester Sport Offers Unique Styling & Improved Off-road Capabilities

If getting to your destination requires going through heavy rain, snow, gravel, or mud, Forester Sport is the trim for you. Forester Sport boasts some visual cues that may or may not be your cup of tea, like LED fog lights and unique 18-inch wheels, but the added benefits of dual-function X-Mode and SI-Drive are sure to help keep your vehicle planted. Serious outdoor enthusiasts should strongly consider Forester Sport.

Adds to or replaces features offered on Forester Premium, plus:

  • Roof rails with integrated tie-downs
  • Color-keyed side mirrors with integrated turn signals
  • 6.3-inch color multi-info. display, dual USB ports
  • Keyless access with push-button start

Forester Limited Adds Luxury Features Like 8″ Touchscreen & Power Liftgate

Forester Limited offers several extremely handy features as standard, such as a power liftgate, LED steering responsive headlights, and keyless access with push-button start. If you find yourself wanting the latest in high-tech features without draining the bank, Forester Premium is for you.

A few of our favorite standard items include blind-spot detection with lane change assist, an eight-inch touchscreen, leather-trimmed seats, and dual-zone automatic climate control.

Adds to or replaces features offered on Forester Premium, plus:

  • 18-inch aluminum-alloy wheels, halogen fog lights
  • Color-keyed side mirrors with integrated turn signals
  • Power rear gate, keyless access with push-button start
  • Dual-function X-mode with hill-descent control

Forester Touring Delivers Luxurious Cabin, Unique Styling, & Many High-end Features

Forester Touring is the top-of-the-line trim, boasting all the tech and features Forester has to offer. If you prefer to live life in the lap of luxury while climbing steep, unforgiving terrain, the Forester Touring is for you. A few of the more noteworthy upgrades include a heated steering wheel, heated rear seats, and reverse automatic braking.

Adds to or replaces features offered on Forester Limited, plus:

  • 18-inch aluminum-alloy wheels
  • Roof rails, LED fog lights
  • Satin chrome side mirrors with integrated turn signals
  • Eight-way power-adjustable front passenger seat
  • Eight-inch infotainment display
car
car
car
car

Pricing for the 2019 Subaru Forester Tops Out at Around $31,500 for a Touring

Subaru Forester - Photo by Subaru

Price ranges for used 2019 Foresters vary based on trim, condition, and history, just like any other vehicle. The examples listed below are according to Kelley Blue Book values for Foresters with 40,000 miles in very good condition and furnished with standard equipment.

Expect to spend about $24,000 for a Base Forester at your local used-car dealer, or around $25k-$27k for a CPO. You can usually find Forester models for around $1,500 less when sold privately, but those carry more risk on average.

If you feel you need a few more options, the mid-tier Premium comes in around $27,500, and the off-road-ready Sport, $29,500.

Limited adds more modern tech, but for a price, averaging about $30k across the used car market. As for the top-end Touring, expect to spend around $31,500 or more, depending on mileage and how well it’s been maintained. The ultimate bargain would be a well-kept, privately sold Touring with low/average mileage for around $29,500.

Though, there’s a certain peace of mind you get when you buy from a dealer, especially if it’s a Subaru Certified Pre-owned (CPO) 2019 Forester.

Where to buy?

$13,595*
Logo chevronRightAlternative
$13,595*
Logo chevronRightAlternative
$27,990*
Logo chevronRightAlternative

*Starting price updated on August 27, 2021.

2019 Subaru Forester: Certified Pre-owned Program Adds Longer Warranty for a Price

Subaru Forester - Photo by Subaru

Subaru boasts one of the best Certified Pre-owned (CPO) programs in the country. Considering their downward trend in the past decade with reliability, this puts buyers at an advantage.

When looking at a CPO Forester, you’re getting a compact SUV with a seven-year/100,000-mile powertrain warranty, 24/7 roadside assistance, and a 152-point inspection. You’re also treated to a $500 owner-loyalty coupon, SiriusXM three-month trial, and a one-year subscription to StarLink Safety Plus with automatic collision notification.

Subaru Forester won KBB’s award for best resale value among compact SUVs in 2020, so expect to pay between $23,000-$34,000 for a CPO 2019 Forester depending on trim and mileage.

Traditional used options will go for about $1,000-$3,000 less than a CPO.

2019 Forester Engine Options Include a Single, Non-turbocharged 2.5-Liter

Subaru Forester - Photo by Subaru

The 2019 Forester features one engine option, the third-gen, 2.5-liter Subaru Boxer engine, or FB25D. The 2.5-liter puts out a modest 182 hp at 5,800 rpm, and 176 lb.-ft. of torque at 4,400 rpm. The 2019 Forester does not feature a turbo option, so that’s all the power available. This engine is paired to a Lineartronic CVT, which features an available seven-speed manual mode with paddle shifters. Towing capacity maxes out at 1,500 lbs.

Production of the 2.5-liter FB25 began in 2010 and replaced the outgoing EJ25 Subaru Boxer engine of the same displacement. Updates were made in 2014, and then in 2019, Subaru added direct-injection technology, boosting power and efficiency.

The 2.5-liter engine is generally considered to be reliable and has an expected lifespan of 200,000 miles. The FB25 platform utilizes a maintenance-free timing chain design and has shed the oil-consumption issues of previous Subaru Boxer engines.

While slightly underpowered for interstate merging or passing maneuvers, the FB25D is a reliable engine with enough grunt to do most jobs without wasting excessive amounts of fuel.

How Many Miles Per Gallon Does a 2019 Subaru Forester Get?

2019 Forester owners reported an average of 26.01 mpg, according to Fuelly. That falls well below the EPA’s rating of 29 mpg combined. The EPA also rates the 2019 Forester as having 26 mpg city and 33 mpg highway. Overall, the vast majority of owners reported mileage averages between 24-29 mpg

The 2019 Forester takes regular unleaded 87 octane fuel and houses a 16.6-gallon tank. Expect to use 3.84 gallons of fuel per every 100 miles in a 2019 Forester.

If gas mileage is a concern of yours, there are others in the segment that fare much better, but the Forester is certainly far from a gas-guzzler.

How Well Does a 2019 Subaru Forester Perform?

Subaru Forester - Photo by Subaru

Performance for the 2019 Forester is a bit of a mixed bag. When it comes to power and torque, you’re not getting much. The FB25 puts out a mere 182 hp and 176 lb.-ft. of torque. These numbers are simply too low for a 3,500 lb. vehicle.

The 2019 Forester makes 0-60 in 9.6 seconds, and traverses the quarter-mile in 17.3 seconds at 82.3 mph. That puts it solidly in the bottom of its class, according to Motor Trend.

The 2019 Forester features four-wheel disc brakes on all trims, with an increase in front brake size to 12.4″ from 11.6″ on the Forester Sport, Limited, and Touring. The 11.2″ rear brakes are standard across all trims.

The AWD system is where the 2019 Forester really shines when considering performance. Subaru’s X-Mode helps to optimize the use of your vehicle’s AWD system. X-Mode utilizes the Vehicle Dynamics Control system to variably control wheelspin to provide maximum traction regardless of the surface.

X-Mode is not available on Forester Base trim, but is offered on all others. Sport, Limited, and Touring models benefit from the dual-function system, with selectable modes for different types of terrain, like snow, dirt, or mud. Forester premium has a single-function X-Mode system.

The 2019 Forester may not have what it takes to compete on the track, but if the trek to the kayaking spot is the goal, you’ll be hard-pressed to find a better vehicle.

2019 Forester Provides Ample Cargo & Interior Space

Subaru Forester - Photo by Subaru

Cargo space is an area where the 2019 Subaru Forester truly shines. With a 105″ wheelbase, and dimensions of 182″ L x 72″ W x 68″ H, Subaru was able to construct a cabin with plenty of space for all your gear. Even if you tend to pack a lot on your trips, you’ll never have to worry about running out of space in the 2019 Forester.

Cargo volume for the 2019 Forester sits at 33 cubic feet, and 35.4 cubic feet without the moonroof. With the rear seats down, cargo volume increases to 70.9 cubic feet, and 76.1 cubic feet without the moonroof. Accessing this space is rather easy with the massive four-foot opening that is the rear liftgate. Throw in roof rails, and you’ll have even more cargo capacity.

Occupants are sure to have plenty of space inside. The Forester’s design allows for adults of six feet or more to sit comfortably in both the front and rear. The 2019 Forester’s superior legroom and headroom are due in part to the high adjustability in the front seats, as well as the large upward greenhouse-style cabin.

You can rest assured that you’ll remain comfortable in your 2019 Forester, and have all the room you need for cargo.

2019 Forester is a Safe SUV Thanks to Plethora of Standard & Available Safety Features

2019 Subaru Forester - Photo by Subaru

Safety is another bright spot for the 2019 Forester. The Forester received stellar ratings in every category of testing and is an excellent option for those concerned with vehicle safety.

Standard Safety Features

  • Lane departure warning with lane keep assist
  • Adaptive cruise control
  • Pre-collision braking
  • Pre-collision throttle management
  • Rear vision camera

Available Safety Features

  • Blind-spot detection with lane-change assist and rear cross-traffic alert
  • Reverse automatic braking
  • Distraction mitigation system
  • StarLink safety and security system

NHTSA Five-Star Rating

The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) awarded the 2019 Forester five stars in every category and subcategory, except rollover, which received four stars due to a 16.9% chance of rollover.

IIHS Top Safety Pick +

The 2019 Forester received a “Good” rating in almost every category and subcategory. Testing was performed by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) using a Forester Premium, and it tested every aspect from roof strength to head restraints and seats. Also, front crash prevention in regard to vehicle-to-vehicle and vehicle-to-pedestrian both scored a “Superior” rating.

Regardless of the trim, the 2019 Forester is one of the safest vehicles available for you and your family.

2019 Forester Technology Features Include Apple CarPlay & Android Auto

Subaru Forester - Photo by Subaru

The 2019 Subaru Forester is loaded with useful technology to make every drive enjoyable, convenient, and safe. With their suite of convenient technologies, Subaru helps to keep drivers focused. A few standard or available items include a lane-departure warning with lane-keep assist, adaptive cruise control, remote start, a backup camera, and Apple CarPlay.

Additional Standard/Optional Extras Include:

  • Pre-collision braking and throttle management
  • Blind-spot detection with lane-change assist
  • Reverse automatic braking
  • Remote start, climate controls, and windshield defrost
  • 6.5-inch or eight-inch touchscreen display
  • Navigation

2019 Forester Offers Limited Exterior & Interior Color Options

The 2019 Subaru Forester’s color options are a welcome addition to the generally dull, small SUV segment. While none of the exterior colors stands out as particularly daring, Subaru kept the boring to a minimum. Jasper Green Metallic and Horizon Blue Pearl stand out as the most vibrant and fun colors offered on the 2019 Forester.

Interior Options:

Interior colors are limited to varying shades of black or gray. If you opt for the leather seating, you’ll be getting the beautiful Saddle Brown.

  • Black Cloth
  • Gray Cloth
  • Premium Gray Cloth
  • Premium Black Cloth
  • Gray Sport Cloth
  • Black Leather
  • Gray Leather
  • Saddle Brown Leather

2019 Forester Reviews: What Critics Said Then & Now

What Critics Say

Car and Driver

The 2019 Subaru Forester is all new and improves on the outgoing model in many ways.

U.S. News

It has a spacious, comfortable interior and a solid combination of safety and predicted reliability ratings.

J.D. Power

This compact SUV is almost all new from the tires up, yet will be instantly familiar to anyone who knows and loves it.

Consumer Reports

The updated Subaru Forester is a smart, well-executed small SUV that boasts a roomy interior, great fuel economy, and plenty of standard safety equipment.

Motor 1

The redesigned crossover continues to do a whole bunch of stuff well, while also improving on the biggest issues that faced the last-generation model.

When the 2019 Subaru Forester first was released, it came out to mostly good reviews. A majority of talking heads were impressed with Subaru’s focus on safety, its spaciousness, storage capacity, and overall ride quality. On the downside, many noted the 2019 Forester’s somewhat sluggish acceleration, lack of a turbo option, and missing features on the lower trims.

Past Critics Reviews of the 2019 Forester

After making the 2019 Subaru Forester his daily driver for a week, auto influencer Brendan Hancock of the Groove Subaru YouTube channel had plenty of thoughts on the then-new Forester. On the positives, he applauded the quiet and comfortable and safe driving experience of the 2019 Subaru.

Hancock also notes that the excellent visibility is due in large part to the 2.5-liter Boxer engine’s ability to sit so low in the engine bay, thus allowing for a dramatically sloped hood. Seat adjustability and the third-panel window design also aided road-viewing efforts in the 2019 Forester.

Lastly, Hancock felt that an increased towing capacity, fog lights on the Premium trim, and factory performance add-ons such as lifts, beefy tires, and skid plates would have sweetened the pot.

Motor Trend had a glowing review for the 2019 Subaru Forester. They loved the 2019 Forester for its spacious cargo area, smooth ride, go-anywhere capabilities, and intuitive tech.

Motor Trend emphasized Forester’s ride height, suspension, and AWD technology as confidence-inspiring for any road condition. They also found the visibility in the 2019 Forester to be the best ever experienced in a compact crossover.

The lone drawback for Motor Trend is Forester’s engine performance, noting that it is a bit slow, but that it shouldn’t be cause for concern in driving situations.

So, how well does the 2019 Subaru Forester hold up after nearly three years on the road?

2019 Forester Current Reviews

In stark contrast to initial reviews, we find that most who have spent considerable time with the 2019 Forester have run into more than a few issues.

YouTubers Steve and Tamami Laser of the website Carnichiwa reviewed a 2019 Forester Touring in 2020 after a year with it, and they had mostly positive things to say about it. The vehicle saw plenty of highway, mountain, and off-road miles. Overall, they enjoyed their time with their 2019 Forester Touring.

In regards to performance, the Lasers felt the Forester was impressive in Sport mode, and did exceptionally well in the rain. They also loved the suite of safety features, especially the reverse auto braking. Lastly, Laser expressed that the 2019 Forester’s versatile cabin was a huge bonus, and the vehicle was reliable in day-to-day driving.

However, they did point out that the auto start-stop feature lacked a smoothness of operation, and was annoyed that the feature must be turned off with each drive if the user wishes not to have it operational.

Auto Blog was less than enthusiastic about the 2019 Forester. During their 21,000 miles of testing, Auto Blog reported their moonroof leaking, among other problems. Most egregiously, by the end of those 21,000 miles, the Auto Blog team was on its third windshield. Overall, they found the Forester to be bland and unimpressive.

Zac Palmer put a lot of highway miles on the Forester during his possession of the vehicle. He shared that the Forester offered comfortable suspension and stellar visibility, but that he only could manage to stay in the driver’s seat a few hours at a time due to its lack of support. Palmer also noted the ride was noisy and highway merging was a bit anxiety-inducing.

“It hits all the fundamentals with a big cargo area, spacious backseat, and solid tech, but I’m left cold,” says Palmer. “There’s no standout feature or must-have angle, and because of that, the Forester melts into the background.”

Byron Hurd found the 2019 Forester to be an absolute monster in the snow with its ground clearance and winter tires.

“If winter capability is a big priority for you, the Forester should be on your to-drive list,” said Hurd. “But even then, I’d probably put a few others ahead of it due to their all-around appeal.”

Joel Stocksdale wasn’t so enthused with his time with the Forester. “The powertrain is the biggest offender,” shared Stocksdale. “The engine is coarse, noisy, and not particularly peppy. And all those characteristics are amplified by the CVT that has a lot of the annoying ‘rubber band’ feel other companies have managed to tune out of their CVTs.”

Stocksdale noted the Forester’s massive interior and second-to-none visibility as wins for the 2019 Forester.

“For some people, the spaciousness, easy maneuverability, and standard all-wheel-drive will make this a useful little box,” remarked Stocksdale. “But I would have a hard time recommending it over many competitors that might sacrifice a bit of space, but return better styling, performance, fuel economy, refinement, and comfort.”

Lastly, John Beltz Snyder shared that when he had the Forester and an Outback in his driveway, he gravitated towards the Outback. Sadly, the Forester couldn’t beat out its own sibling in this segment.

Terry Farmer of the Lucrative Soldier YouTube channel relayed a positive experience overall with his 2019 Forester Sport. At the time of filming, Farmer was close to 42,000 miles on his vehicle. In that time, Farmer did have to replace his windshield, and was happy with the replacement, but still was experiencing chips.

Farmer put a two-inch lift on his vehicle, and noted that the rear brake pads just were replaced (the front pads have yet to need changing). At 42,000 miles, that’s great longevity on pads.

Lastly, Farmer commented that the 2019 Forester’s greenhouse allows for a tremendous amount of heat to get trapped within the cabin. Farmer went for window tints as a solution, and learned that most other owners utilizing the same fix found it did not disrupt the vehicle’s safety features.

2019 Forester Maintenance & Reliability Reports Show a Slightly Problematic SUV

In the world of reliability, Subaru has been falling behind as of late. Subaru ranked 14th among major automakers in J.D. Power’s Vehicle Dependability Study for 2019, with 136 problems per 100 vehicles, equal to the industry average. J.D. Power awarded the 2019 Forester a Quality & Reliability rating of 74/100.

U.S. News gave the 2019 Subaru Forester a below-average predicted reliability rating of 2.5/5

Using reliability reports from Repair Pal, we see that the Forester is estimated to costs about $632, which is about as much as its competitors. The 2019 Ford Escape sits at $32 less per year to maintain, while the 2019 Chevy Equinox runs about $95 less annually.

We recommend that if you are considering the 2019 Forester, you make it a priority to stay on top of regular and preventative maintenance. If you hope to avoid costly repairs, early preventative maintenance will be your best bet.

2019 Subaru Forester: Complaints, Safety Recalls, and Problems

To date, the 2019 Forester has three rather significant recalls, several common issues, and a litany of technical service bulletins (TSBs) addressing potential problems.

Three years after its release, the 2019 Forester has racked up a number of complaints, per reporting site Car Complaints.

Some of the most common include:

  • Front windshield chipping easily
  • Sensitive steering
  • Tailgate becoming inoperable
  • EyeSight safety system malfunction

The 2019 Forester also carries with it a long list of TSBs from Subaru: 363 in total. According to Car Complaints, TSBs are, “official communications between Subaru & their dealerships that describe processes for troubleshooting or fixing certain common problems.” Unfortunately for Subaru, the 2019 Forester carries with it more TSBs than four of its top five competitors.

Recalls

The NHTSA currently lists three recalls for the 2019 Forester:

Rear Stabilizer Bracket Bolts May Detach

  • Issue date: April 15, 2021
  • NHTSA campaign number: 21V263000
  • Resulting issue: Missing bolts may allow the rear stabilizer bracket to shift, increasing the risk of a crash

PCV Valve Can Separate

  • Issue date: December 2, 2019
  • NHTSA campaign number: 19V856000
  • Resulting issue: An unexpected loss of power while driving can increase the risk of a crash

Loss of Electric Power Steering Assist

  • Issue date: February 6, 2019
  • NHTSA campaign number: 19V065000
  • Resulting issue: Loss of power steering assist would require higher steering effort, increasing the risk of a crash.

Ranks #3 Compact SUV by Owners

1
car
4.75
2
car
4.74
3
car
4.72

2019 Subaru Forester Compared to RAV4, CR-V, Equinox, Rogue, & Escape

The 2019 Subaru Forester’s top competitors in the small SUV segment, according to J.D. Power, include the Toyota RAV4, Honda CR-V, Chevrolet Equinox, Nissan Rogue, and Ford Escape. Each vehicle sold more units than the Forester, but much of that is likely due to the limited portion of the population desiring an AWD vehicle, something standard on all Foresters.

2019 Toyota RAV4 is Best-selling Compact SUV & Offers a Hybrid Powertrain

2019 Toyota RAV4 Hybrid - Photo by Toyota
2019 Toyota RAV4 Hybrid

The Toyota RAV4 has been a top competitor in the small SUV segment for decades. As one of the vehicles to pioneer the class, the RAV4 has yet to release its grip on the market. In 2019, the Toyota RAV4 sold more units than any other small SUV in North America.

Selling points for the RAV4 include excellent fuel economy, Toyota Safety Sense suite of standard safety features, reliability, and cargo capacity. Another benefit of the 2019 RAV4 is the availability of a hybrid option, something Subaru failed to offer for the 2019 model year.

Some of the drawbacks of the 2019 RAV4 include an early-shifting transmission and poor handling.

If you need a vehicle far more reliable than the Forester with similar or better safety and (optional) AWD, the 2019 RAV4 may be your best option.

To see a more detailed side-by-side comparison between these vehicles, check out this Vehicle History coverage.

2019 Honda CR-V Lacks vs. Foresters Safety Ratings but Has it Beat in Performance

2019 Honda CR-V - Photo by Honda
2019 Honda CR-V

The 2019 Honda CR-V was the second best-selling compact SUV for the 2019 model year, and for good reason: It’s a great vehicle. Honda’s CR-V struck high notes on interior space, fuel economy, ride comfort, and handling.

Safety ratings on the 2019 CR-V were slightly lower than those on the Forester. The CR-V also suffered from a lack of acceleration power and low towing capacity, but it does offer a turbo option.

Overall, the CR-V is tough to beat. For anyone hoping to add a turbocharged small SUV with exceptional road manners, plenty of cargo space, and fuel efficiency to their driveway, the CR-V is likely the best option.

To see a more detailed side-by-side comparison between these vehicles, check out this Vehicle History coverage.

2019 Chevrolet Equinox is More Affordable & Offers Three Engine Options to Forester’s One

2019 Chevrolet Equinox - Photo by Chevrolet
2019 Chevrolet Equinox

The Equinox, like other top-selling compact SUVs, manages to offer plenty of interior space. Another benefit of the 2019 Equinox is multiple engine options. Chiefly, the 2.0-liter turbo option fares far better than most others in the segment in delivering useful engine power when needed.

Drawbacks of the 2019 Equinox include: actual fuel economy numbers worse than its EPA rating, pricey trim upgrades, and poor headlights. Lastly, the Equinox suffers from a low-quality build and poor materials.

If a basic SUV with engine power is what you need, and price is no factor, the 2019 Chevy Equinox may be the one for you.

To see a more detailed side-by-side comparison between these vehicles, check out this Vehicle History coverage.

2019 Nissan Rogue Falls Short of Forester in Cost Categories

Nissan Rogue - Photo by Nissan
2019 Nissan Rogue

The 2019 Nissan Rogue offers even more cargo space than the Forester when the seats are up, at 39 cubic feet, and matches the Forester with the seats down. The Rogue also matches Forester in gas mileage, at 26 mpg city and 33 mpg highway. If you need more, the Nissan Rogue is offered in a hybrid model.

Perhaps the largest drawback of the Rogue is its safety rating: four out of five stars from the NHTSA. Furthermore, the handling and suspension are poor, and the infotainment system feels very dated.

Although the ride is comfortable and the space plentiful, the Rogue simply doesn’t make a strong case.

To see a more detailed side-by-side comparison between these vehicles, check out this Vehicle History coverage.

2019 Ford Escape Outperforms the Forester but Can’t Match its Spaciousness

2019 Ford Escape - Photo by Ford
2019 Ford Escape

The 2019 Ford Escape packs a healthy amount of Detroit muscle for a compact SUV. At 3,500 lbs., towing capacity is 2,000 lbs. more than the Forester. The 2.0-liter turbo engine option puts out 245 hp and 275 lb.-ft. of torque, far more than the Forester.

Fuel economy and spaciousness are where the Escape suffers. Mileage ratings sit at 23 mpg city and 30 mpg highway respectively. Rear seat legroom is rather precious in the Escape, and interior design leaves a lot to be desired.

If you plan to do a bit of towing with your SUV or simply have a need for speed on grocery runs, take a strong look at the Ford Escape.

To see a more detailed side-by-side comparison between these vehicles, check out this Vehicle History coverage.

Should You Consider Buying a 2019 Subaru Forester?

The 2019 Subaru Forester does a lot of things well. As always, the AWD system simply works. You’ll likely never find it to be inadequate. Cargo space, interior legroom, and visibility are also major plusses. Above all, the 2019 Forester rates exceptionally well for safety.

Sadly, the 2019 Forester lacks in some key areas. Gas mileage is only okay, and lower than advertised in a segment that is managing to put out some real gas-savers. Engine power is utterly lackluster, and the CVT doesn’t do anything to help.

If you’re in the market for a compact SUV, we recommend you consider another model year.

Photos: Subaru; Toyota; Honda; Chevrolet; Nissan; Ford

Frequently Asked Questions

Feb 4, 2022

What is wrong with the 2019 Subaru Forester?

The 2019 Subaru Forester is a relatively new vehicle and there have not been a lot of complaints from owners. The most common issue that has been reported is that the automatic tailgate fails to work from time to time. This is usually caused by a bad sensor, or the electronic latch not releasing properly.

The 2019 Forester also still suffers from the same problems that earlier generations had. This includes the engines consuming excessive amounts of oil. If you get a Forester it is a good idea to make sure to check your oil regularly to make sure that it is full. If your oil levels drop too low it can lead to excessive wear and tear to your engine.

Subaru has improved its quality in recent years which has led to a resurgence for the brand. These are now more popular choices than they were in the past because they are built better and will last longer than they did in the past.

Which 2019 Subaru Forester trim is best?

The 2019 Subaru Forester comes in five different trim levels and each one of them is designed to appeal to a different group of buyers. It is generally accepted that the Sport trim is the best option to go with because it is in the middle of the lineup in terms of pricing and it has all of the capabilities that you would need out of a Forester. This is also a good option because the exterior styling and interior trims are an upgrade over the lower trims.

If you know that you want something more luxurious then the Touring trim is the best one to go with. This will give you the ultimate luxury for your Forester with heated rear seats, upgraded leather, and an upgraded infotainment screen. This does all come at a cost though and the Touring is the most expensive option.

If you know that you are on a budget and want a good deal you can't go wrong with the base trim. This does not have all of the luxury features that the more expensive trims offer, but you still will get the reliability and versatility that you would expect from Subaru.

Why is the 2019 Subaru Forester so popular?

The 2019 Subaru Forester has become a popular vehicle over the years simply because they check a lot of boxes that buyers have on their shopping lists. These are affordable, fuel-efficient, reliable, safe, full of technology, and they have decent cargo room. All of these factors combine to make this a very popular vehicle and that is why they tend to be everywhere these days.

Compact SUVs and crossovers are the most popular vehicles on the road as of 2021 because they give buyers the ability to have the benefits of an SUV with the convenience of a sedan. The Forester is a great example of this because it shares the same drivetrain as smaller vehicles, but has the passenger and cargo room of a small SUV.

The Forester is a great vehicle to look at if you are in the market for something that can give you a lot of versatility. These also hold up well for a long time which makes them a worthwhile purchase for the long run.

Is the 2019 Subaru Forester comfortable?

The 2019 Subaru Forester is considered to be a very comfortable vehicle based on most of the reviews of it. These are more spacious than a lot of the other compact crossovers which makes them a good option if you know that you will need to be carrying passengers around.

The seats in the Forester are also reported to be very comfortable and supportive. If you upgrade to the higher trim options on the Forester you will also get a more luxurious interior with more advanced infotainment and upgraded leather that can make it feel like a much more expensive car.

The Forester also has a suspension that is designed to go over all terrain so that leads to it being more comfortable around town. The suspension on this compact SUV can absorb the bumps and rough patches in the road better than a lot of the competition which makes it much more pleasant to drive.

How long will a 2019 Subaru Forester last?

A 2019 Subaru Forester has an estimated life expectancy of about 200,000 to 250,000 miles as long as you take care of it. Subaru has improved its reliability substantially over the years. In the early 2000s, Subaru had a reputation for failed head gaskets but revisions to the engines have reduced those problems and made them much more reliable.

The most important thing you can do if you want your Forester to last a long time is to take care of it. Minor services like oil changes do go a long way when it comes to helping your car stand up to the test of time. These services will help reduce the wear and tear on your engine components which can help them last much longer.

It is also a good idea to not be too aggressive with your vehicle. If you are constantly taking the vehicle to the red line every time you drive you are just putting extra stress on the engine components. When you drive more sensibly it helps keep the engine in better shape.

Owner Reviews

accountCircle Peter Warburton Shih on August 27, 2021
2019 Forester is a Disappointment!
The tailgate has been a continuing problem as it doesn’t always open and now opens less than one foot and must be then manually pushed up. I’m told that you must hold the open button for 8+ seconds to force it to open. Dealer ordered a part which hopefully will be fixed by next week. Meanwhile, the hazard light is also not working. Although the engine was reported to be delivering more horsepower, it is noisy and labors until it reaches about 30mph. The 2019 Honda CRV is quieter and peppier. Steering was extraordinarily squirrelly and I asked the service manager to check it out. Apparently the “Vehicle Dynamics Control” system was in “on mode” and interfered with my steering. This feature as well as “Eyesight” is something I could and prefer to do without. What I could use are garage openers as standard equipment. I’m told that I can install a special mirror with garage opener buttons at a cost of several hundred dollars.
accountCircle Pamela J on August 28, 2021
2019 Subaru forester sport.
The 2019 Subaru forester is a fantastic vehicle. It has plenty of space and the openness of the car is great. The car is spacious and the windows and windshield are huge. The trunk is a great size for carrying luggage or hauling sports equipment for your kids. It gets good gas mileage and the sport package has a sleek and edgy look. My only complaint is that the cup holders in between the front seats are too far back. They are not comfortable to use when driving. I highly recommend the Subaru forester!
accountCircle Kathleen G on August 28, 2021
Subaru forester 2019: smooth ride.
I love the Subaru forester gas efficiency, turn radius and the front and rear camera. I find it be such a comfortable car with great visibility and a smooth ride. There are potholes everywhere and I barely feel them. The only problem with the eyesight is that it sometimes will auto-break when it is unsafe, even when you are at a safe distance or are already breaking. It will also try to lane correct when you are in the middle of changing lanes or making a right turn.
accountCircle L B on August 27, 2021
2019 Subaru Forester: Navigation system is terrible
I like everything about the Forester, space features, ride. But I hate the new navigation system, had issues with directions in previous year Forester and Outback, with bad directions BUT the 2019 is not user friendly an just plain bad. Planning a future trip and put in address, which is cumbersome,it finds the destination and after 15 minutes still has not come up with directions, 39% after 15 minutes! What a waste of money!
accountCircle Anthony N on August 27, 2021
Subaru 2019 base Forrester.
It runs smooth and has a lot of nice technology features. Comes standard AWD. I liked the dealership that I got it from as well, everyone in the Subaru family was nothing but nice and caring. The Subaru trim of a base was a great choice. Although it is a base Does not seem like that at all. It is truly a premium car and would recommend it to anyone.
accountCircle Ron L on August 28, 2021
Subaru Forester 2019-our first car review
Good performance and reliability. It has good safety features like Eyesight, which makes the car automatically stop if there is red stop light. It also has an amazing infotainment system with android auto and CarPlay which is responsive to touch. Only thing that needs to improvement is the front design of the car which needs to be revamped.
accountCircle Bernard Caron on August 27, 2021
I am driving a Forester Limited 2019 for 3 months now.
No problem. I am very impressed by the Eyesight system which is very effective. Very confortable and quiet except when accelerating. Not as much storage as I would like in the front. The built-in GPS is not so good so I prefer to use Google Map with Android Auto on my phone. Everything else is very good. Maybe not perfect but very close.
accountCircle Sharon S on August 27, 2021
The 2019 sport is compatible with the android auto app.
This is my 3rd Subaru, 2nd forester. The newer model is more spacious, and more technologically advanced than the previous model. My commute is long, so the eyesight feature really comes in handy. Adaptive cruise control is helpful on the long drive. I have never experienced any problems with the performance and reliability of Subaru.
accountCircle Piera L on August 28, 2021
I drive a 2019 Subaru forester & it is great for camping and outdoor activities!
I feel safe driving this car and it has amazing features such as cruise control that adjusts to the vehicle in front of you. It also has a very roomy trunk for camping gear, fishing gear, whatever you need! This car also gets amazing gas mileage! I just refilled my tank for $25 and I had over 500 miles on the last fill up.
accountCircle Frank M on August 28, 2021
2019 Forester Improvements
Excellent looks and innovative features. Excellent safety ratings and safety equipment. Very quiet road noise, excellent pick up, very comfortable and roomy. Much larger trunk capacity than older model, better gas mileage. The new model also has rear AC vents and USB jacks not found on the previous models.
accountCircle Amber D on August 27, 2021
2019 Subaru forester limited review.
Extremely reliable and comfortable! I love the smaller sized SUV that is still stylish and big enough for a family. Not to mention how pet friendly they are! Affordable SUV that has it all including great gas mileage. Love the sunroof and versatility of traveling all over, no matter the weather conditions.
accountCircle Amanda R on August 27, 2021
2019 Subaru forester sport edition is super stylish.
The Subaru forester sport edition vehicle seems very reliable and drives very well, however it is not very fast for a sport car, and the acceleration is not very quick, but it is comfortable, stylish, pretty good on gas, has lots of room, and has up to date technology. It also has lots of safety features.
accountCircle Katie C on August 28, 2021
2019 Subaru forester battery issues.
I recently had my battery die after owning for only 5 months. It wouldn't start at all... Not even able to be jumped by a tow company. I had to have to vehicle towed to the dealership but they replaced same day without a problem. The warranty seems to cover absolutely everything including towing costs.
accountCircle Kelsey R on August 27, 2021
Subaru forester 2019 white review.
I love the eyesight feature where my car can see other cars on the road, warn me if the car ahead of me is stopping fast, and even adjusts cruise control according to the speed of the car in front of me. The backup camera and current mpg is helpful to use every day as well. And of course android auto!
accountCircle Abbie C on August 27, 2021
Love the 2019 Subaru forester!
The 2019 forester drives extremely smooth. There is not a lot of road noise when driving in the highway, and it gets up to speed with plenty of power. I love Apple CarPlay. I also love all of the safety features that Subaru’s have. They are extremely dependable, and they get great gas mileage.
accountCircle Lorna D on August 27, 2021
We love our 2019 Subaru forester!
The forester is fun to drive, nice to look at. We got the sport model. It is white, has black wheels, and orange trim and orange stitching. It has plenty of headroom for my 6'3 husband. The fuel economy is not as good as the outback we had before this. That's my only complaint so far.
accountCircle Mariah A on August 27, 2021
2019 Subaru forester sport.
I love the visibility and safety features of this vehicle. I feel much more confident driving on a busy highway knowing if there is another car in my blind spot. It has plenty of space for hauling around my two large dogs. The apple car play is very convenient, and easy to use.
accountCircle Tina C on August 28, 2021
Blue 2019 Subaru forester.
The 2019 Subaru forester runs really great. The only problem I have experienced with this car is the windshield glass breaking multiple times since purchase. But regardless of that, the car runs perfectly fine and I do not see any terrible problems with it in the long run.
accountCircle Chris D on August 28, 2021
Subaru forester sport 2019.
This car handles extremely well in snow and mud. It does really good on gas. I like the entertainment system and the screen setup. It easily links with iPhones. The trunk is spacious and the seats fold easily. The roof has rack rails installed for multiple types of racks.
accountCircle Savanna L on August 27, 2021
Sub forester 2019 sport edition.
Perfect vehicle for any outdoor adventure! Wanna go camping? Plenty of room is included, heated seats, sunroof with a perfect view, sports edition was my choice. If you're looking for the perfect sporty vehicle, you've found it! Ice silver was my color choice.
accountCircle Marie M on August 27, 2021
2019 Subaru forester love it!
Comfortable, quiet, reliable ride. Forester is roomy inside without being difficult to maneuver/park. Many user friendly features including a backup assist camera, many cup holders, usb ports. . Subaru manufacturers very dependable, well constructed vehicles.
accountCircle Jane W on August 27, 2021
2019 Subaru forester: safety is first.
Handles well on snowy roads and on mountain roads. Nice power in driving up and over mountain passes. It is comfortable to drive in and has lots of room. Really like the eyesight and love the heated seats. Haven't had it long enough to evaluate any problems.
accountCircle Scott C on August 27, 2021
I really have not had any issues with the 2019 Subaru forester.
I did not expect to like the vehicle as much as I do but here I am. My only complaint is that the cruise control only goes by fives. I prefer my cruise control to have better control, but I honestly can't think of anything else that I dislike.
accountCircle Georgia N on August 28, 2021
The 2019 forester is comfortable, reliable, and safe.
I usually hate driving, but I love driving this car. The eyesight features are cool, the GPS system is intuitive, and the design is very stylish. It is also super comfortable to ride in and gets really good gas mileage for its size.
accountCircle Thomas on August 28, 2021
2019 Subaru Forester Camera Broke Already
I have had the 2019 forester sport not even 3 months and brought into the shop for Eye Sight Indicator issue. They tell me they have to order a new camera not happy.
accountCircle emily B on June 25, 2021
Good, standard, reliable family ride.
I like my vehicle in terms of basics: does great in winter driving, good gas mileage, good price, comfortable. I dislike how it looks. I want something more unique, vibrant, fun. This could easily be solved by cooler colors. Also, the upgraded models have a great orange thread trim in the otherwise black interior that really stand out. We got ours used so we didn't have that option.
accountCircle Mauricio S on June 18, 2021
Fun, comfortable family hauler.
Overall it is very reliable, has great room for our family of four and we love the gas mileage. We also love the looks of the exterior, it is very sporty. As for the interior, we love how it looks rugged while still feeling like very comfortable. We really like the stitching and the combination of leather with the neoprene. The oversized sunroof is great and one of the favorite parts of the car for the kids. They love to be able to look out of it at night when the moon is out. Cargo room in the back is very adequate and the bonus roof rails are a huge plus. We've been able to bring larger items on the roof with just the use of some smaller bungee cords. The car handles great and can be fun to drive by switching it to the paddle shifting manual mode.
accountCircle Jennifer J on June 11, 2021
Subaru forester - amazing vehicle!
No problems! Very reliable! Lots of room. Handles great, easy to get in and out of. Hatchback makes it super convenient for loading and unloading. Visibility is great, lots of windows and amazing sunroof. Handles really well in the snow and slick or wet roads. Very safe vehicle.
accountCircle Amanda R on June 10, 2021
2019 Subaru forester sport edition is super stylish.
The Subaru forester sport edition vehicle seems very reliable and drives very well, however it is not very fast for a sport car, and the acceleration is not very quick, but it is comfortable, stylish, pretty good on gas, has lots of room, and has up to date technology. It also has lots of safety features.
accountCircle Ogbemi A on June 3, 2021
Very reliable, affordable, and attractive vehicle.
A very reliable vehicle. Great gas mileage. The road handling is awesome especially with the added feature of the x sport. The size of the vehicle is perfect for when we go camping or taking the pets out or even shopping. Honestly, I'd say this one of the best vehicles I have ever owned. It was affordable and well worth the purchase. I would suggest this for families or single people. It's a gorgeous car on the outside and has all the bells and whistles on the inside.
accountCircle Bernie R on May 27, 2021
It is a very new, innovative, family, and safety car.
The safety of the vehicle is impeccable, I feel extremely safe letting go of the wheel on the highway. There are not many issues with the vehicle. The amount of miles you get per gallon is great as well. It fits all of my children. It has a good amount of space and it automatically detects when you get into the vehicle.
accountCircle Kiely S on May 27, 2021
Camping and traveling for the win!
I have had my forester for almost a year and a half now and I have nothing but wonderful things to say about it. A few of the premium features in my model include heated front seats, a full-sized moon roof, lane correction, and—my personal favorite—adaptive cruise control. These features alone are enough to hook me for life, but the 2019 forester just keeps giving. I love how spacious the backseat leg space is, even when the front seats are almost all the way back. My 6’3” husband can sit comfortably behind my 5’10” self when I am driving without his knees in his chest. There is plenty of space for our car camping setup, and we can easily fit a full 5 adults into the vehicle along with our two large dogs in the hatchback area. 10/10 would recommend, and will likely drive it into the ground before I trade in for anything other than a Subaru forester.
accountCircle April F on May 17, 2021
Great car for the outdoor lover. Will buy again and again!
Great performance and style. The stock tires wore too fast (not due to driver). I like the roominess and clean lines in the interior. Great for the outdoors with its x mode. Hard rubber floor mats are a nice inclusion considering the outdoor lifestyle. Good resale value for years to come.
accountCircle Maggie D on May 13, 2021
2019 Subaru forester, great car!
I love my forester, I have great visibility of the road and it is very comfortable. I also really like the cars computer/radio interface it gives me great options to play music, take calls and display my phones GPS app for hands free directions. The size of the car is really convenient for my family.
accountCircle Daniela J on May 13, 2021
Best Subaru compact SUV ever.
The best car I have ever purchased. Really beautifully designed. The sport trim is very attractive with the orange stitching, partial leather/cloth interior. The only things that would make it better are: change the accent color from orange to red, offer all black interior, and bring back the turbo!
accountCircle Steven M on May 12, 2021
Buy Subaru - you cannot go wrong!
The new Subaru with lane-assist and the cruise control upgrades are awesome - especially in high traffic areas. The seats and a/c make it comfortable, and in the winter the seats are heated which is an added bonus. I had my previous forester for 16 yrs before I traded and I expect this one to last just as long.
accountCircle Sarah C on May 11, 2021
It is extremely slick in appearance.
My car has excellent power. We've taken it off roaring several times and it had handled everything we've thrown at it. The tires have held up really well against punishment on forest roads and we take it backwoods camping and it is done very well. It is extremely comfortable and the heated seats are a must. I would absolutely buy this car again if I had to make the decision again.
accountCircle Amanda B on May 9, 2021
Subaru has outdone itself on its key features.
I am quite happy with my Subaru forester. My gas mileage is fantastic! I never have to use chains in the snow. There is plenty of room for taking trips with the family (lots of legroom as well). I enjoy the features the car has. I especially enjoy its safety features for making sure the car is always at a safe distance, and notification sounds for emergency braking. The only disappointing factor is the seats of the vehicle are not as luxury comfortable as I would like for long trips. After about 3 hours of driving, the seats feel quite firm. This is especially uncomfortable if you are pregnant or have back issues. However, the seats in this vehicle are large enough to fit those who are not of average size, so the firm seats are not that big of a deal for my family.
accountCircle Trinity H on April 29, 2021
This car is perfect for anybody, so many features that make your life easy!
Amazing car, I love how many feature it has and how easy everything is in it. The back and front seats are both very spacious and comfortable. This car can go anywhere and does great in sport mode! My only wish is that it had more horsepower, but of course I knew that when I purchased it. I highly suggest this car for any couple or family that wants a vehicle that can handle any situation and that is convenient.
accountCircle Pat S on April 25, 2021
We love our 2019 forester!
We love our 2019 Subaru forester! The ride is smooth regardless of street or weather conditions - both of which can be suspect living in Chicago. We made the leap to Subaru about a year ago and have not looked back. One of the few downsides is that leather interior upgrades were not available in anything but the higher trim packages.
accountCircle Dave B on April 9, 2021
2019 Subaru forester review.
For while there was a software update needed, all channels on radio would keep resetting. Also had instance where dog blanket got caught in back hatch and drained battery overnight. Wasn't much of warning that back wasn't completely latched. No other issues that we've had.
accountCircle Savannah D on April 4, 2021
Subaru forester makes travel with dogs very comfortable.
The Subaru forester is the perfect vehicle for pet owners. The amount of space is great for my dogs and leaves enough room for luggage. The AWD makes the vehicle feel safe and the panoramic sunroof is an excellent feature. The seats are comfortable and the amount of added features (heated seats, apple carplay, safety detection, etc) make driving this vehicle daily a lot more comfortable.
accountCircle Belinda F on March 29, 2021
Comfortable, but could be designed better.
It handles well, but the electronic features that I bought it for have issues sometimes. Especially the apple CarPlay. It is pretty comfortable for long drives, but the aircon vents are not calibrated right and it comes out of the side vents much stronger than anywhere else.
accountCircle Lily H on March 27, 2021
Eyesight feature has gas and brake assist.
The 2019 Subaru Forester is a 4 out of 5 for me. This is because the cars safety features are too safe! The eyesight feature is good, until there is traffic on the highway, and then the cars pre-collision feature turns on automatically. This is not good because the car slams on the brakes without warning and way too soon. This causes the brakes to wear down very fast.
accountCircle John A on March 26, 2021
Just the rearward camera to see where you are parking and turning.
The touring model of the Subaru forester has all the great aspects. Four wheel drive, camera to see when you reverse. It is just a nice car in general. The performance is great and it gets very good mileage. It is just the best car to have right now.
accountCircle Shannon L on March 25, 2021
Thumbs up on this vehicle.
Car drives smooth, gas mileage is great. Perfect size car with kids. Great for road trips and long drives. Great in snow, eyesight in car is also a plus. Nice moon roof, trunk space is decent while the back seats can fold down. Lots of back space for backseat passengers. Actually pretty comfortable car overall.
accountCircle Zoey M on March 22, 2021
It is the safety features for me.
I moved to Colorado from Texas and fell in love with my friends Subaru so much so that I bought one. I get great gas mileage, the safety features are amazing. From the lane assist, brake assist, and auto adjusting cruise control you will not be disappointed.
accountCircle Renee B on March 20, 2021
2019 Forester Sport Review
It rides smooth, is quiet on the highway, good gas mileage for an SUV. It has a lot of bells and whistles to learn, however. It takes getting used to the auto hold when stopped. I love the sport look and feel! I wish the sunroof would open a few different ways rather than just open or closed.
accountCircle Danny K on March 19, 2021
A mostly great SUV that is fun and safe to drive.
It is very roomy inside compared to the rav4 and CR-V. I also like the safety and reliability that Subaru brings but it stands out in the crowded SUV market. As for dislikes. I had an issues with the rear hatch not opening but was fixed under warranty. The stereo sounds great but cannot play an album in track order via USB. It plays it alphabetically. I also dislike that not all the interior and exterior lights are cool led (some are warm led) and the sunroof button is the only button that does not light up!
accountCircle Liyuan H on March 18, 2021
The greatest radio and surround sounding.
This car is comfortable riding on for a ride, and is great driving for a driver. The seats are in nicely and the motor starts up fast. The radio is also very nice in the car, so is the sounding. The seats are cushioned and very comfortable to sit and drive in.
accountCircle Felipe R on March 9, 2021
Subaru has the best all wheel drive vehicles in the market.
The only actual issue I have with the vehicle is when you are engaged into adaptive cruise control and the vehicle is set to a higher speed than it is currently traveling, when the lane becomes clear, the vehicle will accelerate a bit harshly and uncomfortably. Otherwise, the vehicle is reliable, comfortable, fuel efficient specially for an all wheel drive SUV, as well as spacious and very convenient and easy to live with. I am really happy with my purchase.
accountCircle Emily W on March 6, 2021
Best road trip vehicle of the year.
It's a great daily car, I go hiking a lot and it is four wheel drive and perfect for windy and icy roads up in the mountains. Lots of room in the car, for all the gear (hiking or snowshoeing) plus all my guests. The comfort of the car is great and I drive long trips quite frequently. It performs great and gets relatively good gas mileage for an SUV.
accountCircle Tami B on March 5, 2021
Subaru is a great value and safe.
Drives great. Roomy. Low maintenance. Excellent crash rating. Was hit from behind while stopped. Other driver never braked. Car minimized shock to me. My Forrester was drivable. Other car had so much front end damage it had to be towed. I am on my 3rd Subaru and plan to continue with this manufacturer's cars in the future.
accountCircle Brenda M on March 5, 2021
Subaru forester needs to fix headlights.
Pros:starts easy, looks nice. Like doors locking automatically. Glove department is a decent size, as is the console. The backup guides on the camera are very helpful. The hooks inside the cargo area are helpful to hang groceries on and keep them in place. The automatic cargo door is helpful in opening and closing. Cons: the headlights are a nightmare. They do not project high enough to see road signs. They will not go to bright in totally dark situations.
accountCircle Cassandra T on March 3, 2021
Fun, comfortable and affordable vehicle.
I have had zero issues with this vehicle. It is comfortable to drive and I love it. The sport trim also looks really nice and it is pretty fun to drive. The breaks are very responsive and it turns on a dime for being a good sized vehicle. I honestly have nothing bad to say about it.
accountCircle Kendall H on February 28, 2021
Lots of safety features. Hatch has a good amount of problems.
My favorite things about my car are as follows: I love the interior. I have black and white seats which I love and the whole inside just looks very sleek and new. There are a lot of safety features as well. I have a lot of problems with my hatch opening which has been a huge pain recently.
accountCircle Camille M on February 23, 2021
Subaru Forester premium 2019
No vehicle problems as of yet. The car is only a month old. One thing that I wish was different is the infotainment screen. It's really small compared to my old car. It also buffers sometimes. Another feature that bothers me a little bit is that the back windows do not go all the way Down
accountCircle Anthony J on February 21, 2021
Subaru forester, a brief overview.
The vehicle is very reliable and comfy. The windows are large and make seeing the road very easy. The black color of my car is spectacular and really pops after a nice car wash. The style of the rims I am not fond of but those could be swapped out anytime.
accountCircle Aly K on February 18, 2021
Subaru forester review for families.
Does not ride as nicely as the outback. Louder road noise. The screen also is not as nice as my previous outback. The car is very reliable and has not had any issues to date. It is a good family car but could be small for older kids. Will trade it in when able.
accountCircle Nathanael I on February 8, 2021
Good little wagon, a couple nitpicks.
Overall we really like the forester, it rides comfortably and it drives fairly sporty for its size. We like the large sunroof. Some problems I would mention are an overly sensitive eyesight module that occasionally will start breaking because of traffic in the opposite lane and too many distracting alert sounds that constantly go off during driving.
accountCircle Kelley S on February 7, 2021
It is small and gets pretty good gas mileage
My Subaru forester is my favorite vehicle. It is comfortable and has a lot of room in the back for my children. I love the drive assist features. It almost drives itself while on the highway.The 'Truck' is small but it works for daily commuting. The sport features are a bonus, plus it makes it the best looking forester on the road.
accountCircle Kay B on February 2, 2021
Smooth ride, easy to drive. Smart car features.
Smooth ride, like the sport feature. Gas mileage is okay. Set higher than the Crosstrek so easier to see. I like the blind spot feature and lane shift feature. Wish it came in all leather it is a mix of fabric and leather. Like the all black tires and rims.
accountCircle Charlie R on January 31, 2021
A car that is almost perfect.
The Subaru sport is an amazing car with a very slick interior and a slick trim. The only thing I have come across is sometimes it is a bit loud and I wouldn't recommend the automatic back foot open. Keep it manual. Sometimes it does not open up and it is honestly just such a pain when getting groceries.
accountCircle Jason S on January 30, 2021
The best car you didn't know you could afford.
The forester is a comfortable driving machine. It not only exceeds expectations in all weather conditions, but takes on any challenges the road throws at it. There are few cars that come even close to its comfort. Performance is exceptional, and lives up to it is reputation.
accountCircle Sue B on January 27, 2021
My 1st Subaru is safe and comfortable.
Love everything except for the front windshield is angled so that it is super hot when the sun's out. Have had trouble with the rear liftgate not opening. The interior is very comfortable. I like all the safety features and the packing cruise control.
accountCircle Jamie W on January 25, 2021
It is the safest car out there!
It is very detailed and comfortable on the inside. It is rides very smoothly. It holds well on gas, meaning the money you put into the gas tank goes along way. The interior is high-quality and I do like that the technology in it is up-to-date. I wouldn't say there’s a whole ton of problems. I actually, since it is recently bought, haven't noticed any problems.
accountCircle Gwenn M on January 25, 2021
Subaru forester sport is fun, peppy and reliable.
My Subaru forester is my favorite vehicle I have owned to date. The sport package is eye catching and unique both inside and out, and the seats are very comfortable. The windshield design provides maximum visibility and the headlights are really bright - both of these are great for night driving, which I struggle with. It gets great gas mileage, yet has a punchy acceleration and is super fun to drive. I also love the extended sunroof and excellent sound system. I have not had any performance issues with this vehicle whatsoever and feel confident taking it long distances.
accountCircle Pamela J on January 22, 2021
2019 Subaru forester sport.
The 2019 Subaru forester is a fantastic vehicle. It has plenty of space and the openness of the car is great. The car is spacious and the windows and windshield are huge. The trunk is a great size for carrying luggage or hauling sports equipment for your kids. It gets good gas mileage and the sport package has a sleek and edgy look. My only complaint is that the cup holders in between the front seats are too far back. They are not comfortable to use when driving. I highly recommend the Subaru forester!
accountCircle Jennifer B on January 18, 2021
A great reliable comfortable car.
Not much I dislike. My mirror on sun visor (driver side) broke. I do not like the center console wish there was a space big enough to put my phone & a phone changing pad would be great. I also wish the trunk was a bit bigger. Overall a great car very reliable and comfortable.
accountCircle Linda F on January 17, 2021
Subaru s are pretty great cars.
We love our Subaru. This is the fourth one we have leased. It is easy and fun to drive. We have never had difficulty in the snow due to the all-wheel drive. The 2019 model does require you to use your iPhone to use the GPS. I think I would rather have the GPS built into the car itself.
accountCircle rick B on January 13, 2021
Great car, great features and reliability!
Great ride, acceleration and safe driving technology. Leather seats heated steering wheel, great sound system and very roomy! Night driving lights very good and overall a wonderful dream care to drive. This is my first Subaru and all the hype of owner loyalty and reliability sure seem right on.
accountCircle Joshua N on January 12, 2021
Smart cruise control is perfect for family road trips.
Having put roughly eighteen thousand miles on this car, I can say that it has met my expectations. On the highway it gets about 28 mpg and about 25 in the city. My favorite feature of this car would have to be the smart cruise control, it is perfect for long road trips.
accountCircle Deb A on January 9, 2021
Subaru forester is the right choice.
I love my car. It is a bright, open, airy vehicle. It handles extremely well in snow and bad weather. There’s a lot of up-to-date, modern amenities. The radio, sound system are amazing. It has plenty of storage and the seats fold down. Having all wheel drive all of the time is a relief when the weather turns bad, fast.
accountCircle Ryan B on January 4, 2021
It is a reliable with a lot of space in it.
Pros: camera for reversing car. Warning if I leave my lane or someone is getting to close. A lot of room on the inside. Big trunk with lower seats. Tall off the ground. Stock sound system is good. Con: gas is not the best. Do not like the auto brake system but it can be turned off.
accountCircle Raquel S on December 27, 2020
Subaru forester 2019 overall review.
I absolutely love my Subaru!! It is very smooth to drive, and it is many base fair tires are so helpful. The alerts it gives me when I am drifting out of a lane are super helpful and I love the automated cruise control it incorporates to keep me from even drifting. The mirrors are excellent, I can see almost everything and the blind spot is relatively small. The lights on the side of the mirrors are super helpful when letting me know if there is a car in my blind spot. I have never had any issues with my Subaru, I highly recommend. It is also one of the most comfortable cars I have ever sat and drove in, makes road trips even better comfort wise!! I love the sound system, and the apple CarPlay feature is super awesome and easy to maneuver. Once again, I love my Subaru!
avatar Tyler Linn
Tyler joined Vehicle History as a contributing writer in 2021 and has worked in the automotive industry as a journalist since 2019. His area of expertise lies in '80s and '90s Japanese imports and Toyota/Lexus vehicles. When he's not writing, Tyler likes to jam out to screamo or synthwave in his '94 Toyota Soarer as he pushes it through the twisties with his car club. Check out his poor taste in photography and Christian memes via IG: @tylerlinn5
  • Articles
  • chevronRightAlternative
  • Used 2019 Subaru Forester Buyer’s Guide